• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

John August

  • Arlo Finch
  • Scriptnotes
  • Library
  • Store
  • About

Good writing vs. the idea

September 10, 2003 Film Industry, QandA

If your screenplay is good enough will that guarantee it recognition or is
it more in the selling of the idea?

–Brett

A screenplay that is "good
enough" won’t get any recognition at all.
Unless it has an ingeniously compelling (and marketable) idea, a script has
to be ungodly well-written to attract much attention. Of course, the best scripts
have both a brilliant idea and brilliant execution, but that’s not your question.

Let’s say you decide to write a family drama. Unless it’s about a family of
killer robots, the "idea" of the story is not what will make it sell.
So you better have some fantastic writing in there to make it compelling.

On the other hand, the family-of-killer-robots script could conceivably sell
even with some sub-par writing, if it does a good job presenting the idea and
studios happen to be in the market for killer robots with a twist. Here’s the
big difference between the two kinds of scripts: if you write a extremely well-written
script that no one buys, you’ve still written a great script. On the other
hand, if you write a crappy script (even with a great idea) and no one buys
it, all you have to show for it is a crappy script.

Related Posts

  1. Process of writing
  2. My idea’s been stolen
  3. Got the story, but I can’t write

Primary Sidebar

Newsletter

Inneresting Logo A Quote-Unquote Newsletter about Writing
Read Now

Explore

Projects

  • Aladdin (1)
  • Arlo Finch (27)
  • Big Fish (88)
  • Charlie (39)
  • Charlie's Angels (16)
  • Chosen (2)
  • Corpse Bride (9)
  • Dead Projects (18)
  • Frankenweenie (10)
  • Go (30)
  • Karateka (4)
  • Monsterpocalypse (3)
  • One Hit Kill (6)
  • Ops (6)
  • Preacher (2)
  • Prince of Persia (13)
  • Shazam (6)
  • Snake People (6)
  • Tarzan (5)
  • The Nines (118)
  • The Remnants (12)
  • The Variant (22)

Apps

  • Bronson (14)
  • FDX Reader (11)
  • Fountain (32)
  • Highland (73)
  • Less IMDb (4)
  • Weekend Read (64)

Recommended Reading

  • First Person (88)
  • Geek Alert (151)
  • WGA (162)
  • Workspace (19)

Screenwriting Q&A

  • Adaptation (66)
  • Directors (90)
  • Education (49)
  • Film Industry (491)
  • Formatting (129)
  • Genres (90)
  • Glossary (6)
  • Pitches (29)
  • Producers (59)
  • Psych 101 (119)
  • Rights and Copyright (96)
  • So-Called Experts (47)
  • Story and Plot (170)
  • Television (164)
  • Treatments (21)
  • Words on the page (237)
  • Writing Process (178)

More screenwriting Q&A at screenwriting.io

© 2025 John August — All Rights Reserved.