• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

John August

  • Arlo Finch
  • Scriptnotes
  • Library
  • Store
  • About

Revisiting The Dropout

Episode - 758

Listen on

  • Apple Podcasts
  • Spotify
  • RSS
  • YouTube

October 27, 2026 Scriptnotes

What are storytellers’ responsibilities when it comes to real-life figures? How much fiction can you blend with fact?

You Can See Everything is the latest film exploring Elizabeth Holmes, the fascinating and singular Theranos founder. In light of its cultural moment, this week we revisit episode 546, where John is joined by Liz Meriwether and Liz Hannah to discuss their own Liz Holmes series, The Dropout, starring Amanda Seyfried.

No spoilers in the main show, but in our mega-bonus segment for premium subscribers, John, Craig, Drew, Meredith and Lauren have a spoiler-filled roundtable discussion of their You Can See Everything experiences. Unsurprisingly, Craig has strong opinions.

Download the episode here!

Get your copy of The Scriptnotes Book and become a Scriptnotes Premium member today! For more content on the craft of writing check out Inneresting our weekly-ish newsletter about screenwriting and things that are interesting to screenwriters.

Scriptnotes is produced by Meredith Stedman and edited by Matthew Chilelli. Our coordinator is Lauren Loesberg.

Outro by Gloom Canyon (send us yours!)

Email us at ask@johnaugust.com

Full Episode Transcript:

  • Prologue
  • Flashback: Writing Dropout and Plainville
  • Flashback: On Set, Legal, and Ethics
  • Flashback: Pitching the Next True Story
  • One Cool Thing
  • Bonus Segment

Prologue

John August: Hello and welcome. My name is John August.

Craig Mazin: Hello and welcome. My name is John August… *Craig Mazin.*

John: This is episode 758 of Scriptnotes. It’s a podcast about screenwriting and things that are interesting to screenwriters. Often on this show, we are discussing how would this be a movie or a limited series. In episode 546, we sat down with Liz Meriweather and Liz Hannah to talk about their adaptations of true stories, including The Dropout, which explored the rise and fall of Elizabeth Holmes and her company, Theranos. Craig, have you heard of them?

Craig: Yes, I have heard of all of the people and places you just said.

John: Exactly. A new movie tells Elizabeth Holmes’s side of the story and calls into question what is truth? What is performance? What do words actually mean?

Craig: What words do actually mean, do?

John: No. Can, could. Yes. There’ll be no spoilers about that film in this discussion. As we revisit our 2022 conversation with Liz and Liz about Liz, we will then come back for a bonus segment where we’ll have a spoiler-filled mega-banter about You Can See Everything with me and Craig, plus Meredith, Lauren, and Drew, who’s still around in this universe.

Craig: I don’t like the way you put it.

John: Yes, me either.
[laughter]

Craig: Who won’t leave.

John: A big-filled episode, so 2022, but also today. Most crucially, we are about to head to Austin, Craig. Do you remember that we’re going to Austin?

Craig: I remember that we’re going to Austin.

John: You’re flying from Vancouver to Austin specifically for this.

Craig: I got to tell you, Vancouver to Austin is not easy.

John: Yes, everyone’s doing it.

Craig: Yes, unsurprisingly, not a direct flight. I detest non-direct flights. Detest.

John: Sorry, but we’re not at the private jet stage.

Craig: Well, John, don’t tempt me, Frodo.

John: [laughs] With all that script, that’s funny. We are going to be going to Austin for the Austin Film Festival. We are doing a live show on Friday night. We are doing a three-page challenge on Saturday morning, too early for Craig’s taste.

Craig: Unbelievable. Look at it. We go in there Friday night. Our show at Friday night is at-

John: 9:00 PM.

Craig: -9:00 PM. It’s going to be a two-hour deal. The show, then meet and greet, and all the rest. Now it’s 11:00 PM. I’m going to get back to my room, get ready for bed. By the time I really get ready for bed, if I’m lucky, I’m going to sleep at midnight if I’m lucky. Now lately, I don’t know about you, John, I’m not sleeping eight hours. No, it’s hard. What’s going to happen is I’ll probably sleep five hours, and then the amount of time I would need to go back to sleep is gone. I’ll be very tired, and then I have to go do a three-page challenge John’s making me do.

John: Yes, sorry, I’m making you do this.

Craig: At 9:00 AM in a church.

John: I specifically honestly asked for the early slot because I was trying to fly back, and there were not flights that could get me back to LA in time. I’m sorry.

Craig: Which he doesn’t need to do anymore.

John: It’s my fault.

Craig: You don’t even need to do that anymore.

John: No, no.

Craig: Why don’t we ask them and see if they can-

John: No, they’re not going to switch things at the last minute. It’s too late for that.

Craig: They might for us.

John: We also tried to get some sort of book signing happening at a bookstore that we just couldn’t make it happen. If you are at the festival and you have your Scriptnotes book, awesome, and we’ll sign it. Whenever you see us, ask us to sign your book, we’ll sign your book.

Craig: $7.50.

John: No, it is thank you for buying the Scriptnotes book. Last time we were there, we were talking about the book as a thing that could exist in the future. Now it exists.

Craig: If you are an emotionally explosive person in a, let’s call it, a two-way abusive relationship with someone, and you guys throw stuff at each other, strong recommend that you buy the Scriptnotes book. It’s very light.

John: It’s very light.

Craig: The likelihood that it will do serious damage is low.

John: It would have to hit one of the four-

Craig: You’d have to catch a corner.

John: Corner.

Craig: Even then, I got to say-

John: Half of the corners are soft.

Craig: Plus, is it going to even get to you? Because halfway through the air, I just think-
Joh: Absolutely. It could float off.

Craig: Resistance-

John: It’s hard to throw.

Craig: It’s a good choice.

John: It’s a safe.

Craig: It’s a safe bet.

John: [crosstalk] While we’re talking about the Scriptnotes book, one of the things I’ve noticed in stores is sometimes a bookstore, I’ll go in there and I’ll find, do they have a Scriptnotes book? Yes, but they don’t have it filed with Save the Cat and the other screenwriting books. They have it filed with reference. It’s like, “Well, yes, it is a reference, but it’s not a dictionary.” because I think we should be filed with other books about screenwriting.

Craig: Naturally.

John: Naturally, if you are in a bookstore and you see it misfiled, tell them. If you work at a bookstore, if you work for Barnes & Noble, for example, at the Grove, maybe move it to the place where you used to have it.

Craig: Do they have some sort of corporate-

John: There’s some sort of algorithm.

Craig: Is there algorithm?

John: I think what it is there’s some kind of Dewey Decimal System-ish thing that tells what kind of book it is, and it’s miscoded for some people.

Craig: Well, let’s throw the book at them.

John: Aha. Craig, we also love to see Scriptnotes T-shirts, which are nice and soft.

Craig: Nice and soft.

John: If you’re at the Allison Film Festival and want to wear a Scriptnotes T-shirt, they may notice it, and people will say, “What’s that great shirt?” We’ve been doing this for 15 years, and people have the vintage shirts that we don’t even make anymore.

Craig: That’s true.

John: I have not seen those in a while.

Craig: Absolutely. I, on the other hand, I’m intimidated.

John: If you wear our merch?

Craig: Yes. This is basically the difference right there [chuckles].

John: I would also recommend you follow us at Scriptnotes Podcast on Instagram and tag us in any photos you take. Also look for maybe some potential special announcements while we’re at the festival there. It could be worthwhile to follow the Scriptnotes Podcast if you’re going to be coming to Austin.

Craig: I can’t wait to find out what it is.

John: Yes. Even Meredith doesn’t know what my plan is here. That’s always great to see. We have a little bit of follow-up here. Craig, you had a recommendation on a previous episode about standing ovations. Some people wrote in to say that at the end of last episode because Matthew cut in a one-minute standing ovation followed by air horns.

Craig: Amazing. I can only assume that around the 20th second of that minute, people are like, “Okay, ha, ha, ha, stop.” Now imagine 18 more minutes.

John: Even within that one minute, there are waves of like, I’ll wait until it built up again. [crosstalk]

Craig: It’s insane.

John: It’s insane. Air horns are the solution.

Craig: [onomatopoeia]

John: Done.

Craig: Exactly.

John: We have follow-up about screening rooms, watching movies at home, watching big screens from a listener with experience in Taiwan. Meredith, help us out.

Meredith: Sure. After your recent discussion about screens and how we watch films, I wanted to get in touch with a fascinating little piece of Taiwanese film culture history. In Taiwan in the ‘90s, they had places called MTV, which stands for movie TV, which were video and laser disc libraries where you could rent a private screening room to watch a film with friends. These weren’t just little rooms with televisions. Many had enormous, for the time, high-quality screens, very decent sound systems, and comfy sofas.
You could even use the telephone in the room to order room service. Anything from snacks to meals, cigarettes, and alcohol. MTVs were an experience I haven’t seen or heard of elsewhere. As Taiwanese homes were often small and multi-generational, young people had limited privacy. MTVs offered somewhere to socialize, watch films, or spend time with a date.
Their demise began while I was there. Copyright concerns and licensing violations and pressure from Hollywood studios contributed to a significant crackdown. Some survived with random police checks to ensure no infringement was taking place. Their counterpart, KTVs, or karaoke, then swooped in and took the market.

Craig: I was listening to this and imagining somebody going, “Wait, we should have that here.” Then me having to explain, it’s copyright, exhibition, there’s a rule. When they sell you a DVD or a videocassette, which nobody buys anymore, or when we stream things, the terms of service, we are allowed to exhibit those for our personal use. They literally back in the day would say, “Hey, if you have a party where there are 30 people come over to watch a movie in your house, you’re exhibiting it now.” It’s a whole weird thing. Obviously, they never really went after anybody for that. This is precisely what they were terrified of and theater owners even more terrified of.

John: Yes. I fully understand the instinct here because places where you don’t have your own personal space, to be able to go to a place to hang out because we talk about how it’s great to see a movie in a dark theater where everyone’s quiet and respectful, but it also can be fun to watch a movie with your friends on the couch. If you don’t have that space to have a place you can go to do it is fun and cool. I would love if somebody could figure out the business model where we can license things properly to do this kind of stuff. I’d love for someone to try this experiment again.

Craig: Theaters have been moving towards this in their own way. When you and I would go to theaters as kids, it was just, “Here’s your tiny seat, F you.” Now you’ve got the big seats, they recline, there’s a menu, people bring you food. They don’t bring you cigarettes or alcohol because it’s not Taiwan in the ‘90s.

John: I’m sure [unintelligible 00:08:46] were bringing alcohol.

Craig: There you go. It’s finding its way to an interesting middle ground. I personally miss the old, particularly for comedies. Everybody was just jammed together.

John: You can top the jokes and stuff like that when you’re there with friends. It’s fun.

Craig: Top the jokes?

John: Yes. Basically, you’re laughing at the thing and also anticipating the jokes. We’re just watching something that’s familiar to you. You’re watching with friends who are like, “I’ve seen this movie, you haven’t seen the movie, I get to watch the movie with you.” It’s great.

Craig: Exactly. I thought you meant like, do better than the jokes on the screen.

John: Oh, that too.

Craig: No, shut up. [laughs] You’re in a movie theater.

John: Oh, that’s what I’m saying. The difference between a movie theater. I think there’s a social aspect when you actually can talk over the movie, that’s great if you’re in the right setting for that.

Craig: Yes, if you’re home.

John: That’s why I feel like there needs to be a space for you’re not at home, but you’re able to gather with friends. The same way a karaoke bar, you could just do karaoke at home, but it’s fun to have a space that’s designed for it.

Craig: Televisions now, if you think about the ‘90s, televisions were just square. People now, everybody’s got the big flat screen, it’s wide, the sound bar. That is your home. I think you have it.

John: Yes, but it’s isolated. It’s just to yourself. People don’t have-

Craig: You can bring your friends over.

John: Yes, if you have the space to have friends. If you have friends and a space that’s big enough to do it, because we’re a small in Los Angeles where we have comparatively a lot of space to people in New York City.

Craig: True, but I don’t know. In all those movies about New York, or shows, like Friends, they have so much space. I don’t know what anyone’s whining about.

John: Absolutely. [unintelligible 00:10:24] great.

Craig: They’re barely getting along. She works at a Starbucks, Central Perk. Her apartment is really small, you guys.

John: It is. We’re going to segue over to our discussion from 2022 and hear from Liz Merriweather and Liz Hannah about the dropout and the girl from Plainville. This is relevant to our conversation, but what’s also relevant is we have a 2021 interview with Lance Oppenheim, who is a co-director of You Can See Everything. We were talking about it in an earlier film with his, but you get a sense of his methodology. Reminder that if you’re a Scriptnotes premium listener, you can go back and listen to any old episode at any time you want to. A good excuse for going back and listening.

Craig: All there for you.

John: It’s all there for you.

Craig: It’s part of the $5 a month.

John: Listen now to this segment from 2022, and then we’ll be back at the end with our One Cool Thing, and then our bonus segment about You Can See Everything.
[music]

Flashback: Writing Dropout and Plainville

↑ Back to Top
Let’s talk about this moment we’re in right now with limited series that are based on actual events, because there’s so many on TV right now. We have your two shows. We have The Dropout, The Girl From Plainville, but we also have WeCrashed. The Thing About Pam, Super Pumped, Inventing Anna, Pam and Tommy, The Tinder Swindler. This is a moment where a lot of these things are happening. I want to start with your two shows, and maybe we’ll start with The Dropout. Liz Meriweather, how did the dropout come to be? What was the first thing? Was this something you pursued? Did they come to you? What was the origin story for The Dropout and the story of Elizabeth Holmes?
Liz Meriweather: I was finishing New Girl, and Searchlight contacted me because they had optioned the podcast, The Dropout, which is an incredible podcast, and anyone who’s interested in the story should listen to it. They had Kate McKinnon already attached, and it was already set up at Hulu. They were just like, “We have everything in place, we just need a writer.” Just a little thing.

John: It’s not a small thing.

Liz Meriwether: I do feel like Searchlight, this was their first television show, so I think they coming at it with more of the movie thing of, “We just need a writer.” It’s like, “No, welcome to television.” I had read Nick Bilton’s Vanity Fair article. There was a really big article on Vanity Fair when Theranos was falling apart, and I’d read it, I think, a couple of years before Searchlight contacted me, and I loved the story. I just hadn’t done anything with it. I was familiar with the story. By the time they contacted me, I just had that feeling like there’s been a documentary, there’s been a book, there’s been a lot of reporting about it. I think at that point, there were some companies in Silicon Valley that had Elizabeth Holmes Fridays, or whatever. Didn’t we find that out, Hannah, that they’d been dressing up like employees?

Liz Hannah: When we were in the room, I was in Austin for something, and it was Halloween, and I saw three Elizabeth Holmeses walk in. I was like, this is before the show. It was like, I think I texted you guys. It was like, “What goes next?” Everybody already dresses like her.

Liz Meriwether: The story was definitely in the news. I had that question that I’m sure you had too, Hannah, which was just like, “Why does this need to be dramatized? Why does this need to be a limited series?” I think that answer, I came up with was that I felt like it hadn’t been told from her point of view. Her interior world hadn’t been explored. I thought it would add to the story. I thought it kind of like, the only people who can do that are writers. It’s not the job of journalists to picture themselves in somebody’s shoes. I felt like that would really add to the story.
I went in for the meeting, and as I was talking about it in the meeting, I just got more and more animated. I just found myself getting really emotionally involved in the actual meeting. I had that out-of-body experience where I was like, “Oh, I really want this to come out. I really care about the story,” which is never good in the meeting.

Liz Hannah: To realize it, yes.

John: You’re talking yourself into it, yes.

Liz Meriwether: Because then you’re like, I’m not going to be able to walk away from this. Then Hannah hired Liz Helden’s incredible drama writers because I had no drama experience and really knew that I needed help in that way. Then we wrote it, and we were supposed to start shooting March 2020. Then COVID happened, and we lost our director and Kate McKinnis. Then spent a year trying to put it all back together again.

Craig: I definitely want to focus on the writing of this because I’m so curious what your process was going into it. You’d run shows before where you’re cranking out 20 episodes, 24 episodes in a year. This is such a different beast. Before we get to the writing of it, I’m curious what the origin story was for The Girl From Plainville. This is again based on a real story of a young woman who is accused of leading another teenager into suicide. What was the start of this? Was there a book? Was there an article? Who came to who with the idea of doing this?

Liz Hannah: There was an article called The Girl From Plainville by Jessie Bannon Esquire. I had not read it. I’d heard about it. I’d obviously heard of the case, but really in a peripheral way. I think in maybe how we all knew it, which was I knew it happened. I knew less about that than I knew about Elizabeth Holmes upon being approached to do The Dropout. I hadn’t listened to The Dropout podcast, but knew it existed and knew more about her, at least in the zeitgeist, than I did about Michelle Carter. The article existed. Then there was the documentary. I Love You, Now Die by Aaron Lee Carr that was on HBO. Universal had optioned the article.
Patrick McManus, my co-creator and co-showrunner, was attached to do it, but really wanted a partner on it. I didn’t feel that he could or wanted to tell the story all by himself. L Fanning was considering doing it. I had worked with L previously. We’d been looking for things to do again together. They brought it to me. I was like, hard pass. We were still in the room on The Dropout, I think, when they approached. A similar approach, which was like, why do this? What is there to add to this story? Also, I was like, “I’ve just spent a long time unpacking the interior life of a quite complicated woman who everyone hates. I don’t know if I want to dive into that again.”
I didn’t read the article until L wouldn’t take no for an answer, and neither would Brittany Conward, who’s my manager and our producing partner. I read the article. The thing that really struck me was, similar to Elizabeth Holmes, which was like, there’s so much more to this girl to unpack. Also, that I really felt like she had been depicted in a very salacious way in the media that maybe undercut some of the larger conversations to be had about the case itself and about the relationship itself. I think very dismissively talked about suicide rather than having a larger conversation about mental health and the toxicity of this relationship and the toxicity of technology and all of these things.
I felt very of now to tell that story. This was in December 2019. Patrick and I sat down to write the pilot, and we were going to take it out, and then the pandemic happened. Weirdly, the thing that I couldn’t relate to in the show was how you could be so consumed by your phone. I’m consumed by social media, but I don’t have the religious relationship to my phone because I didn’t grow up with it. It’s a different experience to just not have been 12 and have an iPhone or a Twitter account, and to not necessarily understand the connection that you can have with somebody that’s a distance between that black mirror. Then the pandemic happened, and I was like, every relationship I had was with everybody over a phone. It became very timely in a weird way.
That was really where it started, and very similar to why I was interested in doing The Dropout, which, frankly, was because Meriweather was doing it. I was like, there’s a why now aspect, which I think is interesting, but there’s also a voice aspect, which is, I think Meriweather is one of the best writers I know, and I wanted to work with her and hear that. That was really exciting. I think when you decide to do one of these things, it’s what we’ve been talking about. It’s like, unless it’s going to be additive, then it just feels like we’re putting another thing on television, and there’s enough.

John: From the start, did you guys know how many episodes each of these series was going to be? Meriweather, did you know that this was going to be X number of shows?

Liz Meriwether: This is funny because Hannah knows all of the answers to these questions.

John: If your voice fails, Hannah can just keep going.

Liz Hannah: This one’s a really funny one.

Liz Meriwether: First of all, I was terrified of drama, and I was terrified of drama-length stories and drama-length scripts. I was like, six, it’s definitely six, which felt like the shortest amount that you could do, and I was also like, I don’t know how much the audience is going to want to engage with this story. Then we started researching it and working on it and interviewing people, and it just kept getting bigger and bigger. It just became clear that six wasn’t going to be enough, but for a long time, it was seven or eight. It was either going to be seven or eight.

Liz Hannah: Unless you had asked Dan LeFranc, who still wants 10 episodes.

Liz Meriwether: He’s still working on two more. Even after the writers room ended, Hulu was still like, by the way, they were incredibly patient with me, but it was up to a point where they were like, “We need to know we’re making a budget. We need to know if this is seven or eight episodes.” I finally was just like eight because I needed them to budget in case it needed to be eight. I think what I was so afraid of was that the eighth episode was going to feel like it was just wrapping up. I think what was tricky about The Dropout story was that, in my mind at least, and I think people who are familiar with the story, and anybody who’s seen All The President’s Men or what, it’s just like that first article comes out and you’re like, that’s the end of the story.
The more I was reading about what happened afterwards, I realized that really, that article actually didn’t actually stop there. It was a mix of the article and just this federal agency.

Liz Hannah: Bureaucracy.

Liz Meriwether: Yes, bureaucracy. Then in the room, in the writers room, we talked a lot about wanting to end at Burning Man, which was always the dream that we were going to end it with her and Billy at Burning Man.

Liz Hannah: There was an acid trip in there at one point. There was a lot.

Liz Meriwether: I feel like, Hannah, we’ve never talked about this, but I credit Coase for stopping the Burning Man dream because what had been Burning Man turned into one woman getting into an Uber.

Liz Hannah: It is actually amazing that the whole process takes place in a short amount of time. There was an acid trip and there was a burning down of something. It’s the burning down of the building thing.

Liz Meriwether: Who knows? What about you? Did you know what the amount of episode was, Hannah? How did that work?

Liz Hannah: I think we always knew it was eight. I don’t know. It felt like not 10 and not six. It was like that felt like a nice round number. I kind of-

John: Was that a creative decision or was that sort of like, this is economically viable to do eight episodes, whereas six is too few for us to pay out and 10 is-

Liz Hannah: It’s a bit of both. Six is really hard to convince a studio to do. They just don’t make money back when it’s six for a sundry of reasons. I think you could maybe get away with seven if you were like, creatively, it doesn’t make sense for us to have an eighth, and you made a real case for it. In all frankness, I think there’s a bit of extension that happens in Plainville for the eighth episode.
At the same time, we also knew that we wanted to give Conrad a full day. His last day is an entire episode and give him his moment. Knowing that, then backed us into the eighth. We definitely never were like, there’s more to the story after that. Dan also wasn’t in the Plainville room. I’m sure had he been, we would still be talking about parts nine and 10 of Plainville.

Liz Meriwether: It was so foreign to me, just as somebody who had spent eight years being told everything we had to do, and to the point where I think it was the first season when we were really ahead. After you plan a whole season and getting a call towards the end, it’s like, “You need to put two more episodes on the air.” I almost felt like I had too much freedom, or it was just like, “Well, how many episodes do you want it to be?” I’m like, “What? What is this alternate universe where I get to decide things?” I put off the decision for as long as I could.

Liz Hannah: Length was also a weird thing for me. I know we did this in the room for Dropout, too. They paged length. They were like,”If it has a five in front of it, that’s maybe a problem,” but they wouldn’t push back on it. Then in post, I don’t know if you had a similar experience, but in post, it was like, we had the number, the amount of minutes it had to be for international sales, and that was it. It was like, as long as it hits this, which I think for us was 42 minutes. Our episode length could really be anywhere from 42 to 60 minutes and could even go over if it needed to. We don’t, but we had that conversation.
That was really weird and interesting to have this, there’s no handcuffs. If this is a 40-minute episode, then it’s a 40-minute episode, and do whatever is creatively right for it.

Liz Meriwether: I strong-armed them. I’m not good without limits. I was like, “Just tell me what is the best time for episodes to be.” They finally gave in and were like 51, 52. Then I went into post with that in mind because this was so foreign to me. I was used to hitting 21, 35, no matter what, and to the point where you’re like, we called it ball shaving. I don’t know if we should.

John: That’s awesome.

Liz Meriwether: To the point where I was in with the editor taking frames out of shot. It was so bizarre to me to have that kind of freedom.

John: Now, before you get to the ball shaving and the final post of it all, you have to write these episodes. Let’s talk about the writing of the two shows because from what you’re describing, it doesn’t sound like what I expected because, Hannah, I assumed you came in after there was a pilot and after there was an order, but it sounds like you were earlier than that. Hannah, let’s start with Girl From Plainville, which I think might be a little bit more normal. You’re at Universal. They say, okay, we want you to do the show and then they’re going to take it to Hulu. Did you guys write a pilot episode first before you wrote everything else? Talk to me about that pilot and what other documents did you write at the same time?

Liz Hannah: We wrote a pilot and a pitch document and that was it. We also had the article and Aaron Lee Carr was on as consulting producer on the show. We had Aaron and Jesse there for anything. The pilot that we wrote and then that was how we sold the show. Aside from removing some scenes, it’s pretty close to what’s on the air. There’s not a lot that changed. There’s one-

Liz Meriwether: It’s so good, by the way.

Liz Hannah: Thank you. There’s a writing motif, I was just telling somebody about this earlier, that we had in the show. I don’t know that we need past, present, fantasy, text fantasy, and then this other thing on top of it, so that’s no longer in there. Other than that, it was that. We sold it to Hulu. It was the same partners I worked with on The Dropout. Then we opened the room and it was pretty straightforward. We had a 20-week room. We wrote six out of eight in the room and then I wrote seven and then Patrick and I wrote eight. We had outlines, I think, for, we knew what eight was always going to be, so we had that done and then we just had to write it, which we did about four days before we went into production.

John: All right. Universal’s hiring you guys to write this pilot and you guys are writing this pitch document before you’re going out to pitching it to the Hulus and the other potential distributors for it. What is a pitch document like for this? What’s in that and how long is it? Is it a keynote? Is it a PDF? What is the pitch document like?

Liz Hannah: The greatest thing that ever happened was that I didn’t have to drive to Santa Monica four times randomly over the course of two weeks because it was all on Zoom. I don’t know that I’ll ever go back to pitching in person. It was glorious because also, guess what? Little pages document right up on the screen. You can’t see it and I can’t see you and I can just read and it’s great. I can ad-lib and do my little schtick. It was great. That was it.
The document was why we had come to the show. It was a synopsis of the pilot because generally, no one reads the pilot until they hear the pitch and then they’re like, “Oh, maybe.” and then they read it. You have to do the like, so you remember when you read in the pilot that you didn’t read, but these things happened. [chuckling] Then it was like, here’s what the show will be. We had talked about, we went into it with what are the ways that people will pass on the show?
We knew putting the texting out there was a way to pass because it’s the thing we’ve all been trying to figure out how to do for the last 20 years is put texting on screen and not make it just subtitles or just I’m reading my phone and seeing texting. Patrick, in our very first meeting, had pitched me the idea of their last conversation being in person. Then we took that and ran with it through the whole show of having these texting reenactments of them being in the same place together. That was in the pitch. Then we had the Glee fantasies in the pitch. They were not musical numbers yet, but they did have those.

John: This document, you’re sending this through as a PDF. Is it just text or do you have images?

Liz Hannah: Just text. It’s interesting. Yes. I don’t do a visual component to pitching. I’ll either become too obsessive about it or I distract myself and then I don’t write the actual document. I’m like, “Look at all the pretty pictures.” I know people that do it. My husband is a writer-producer and he uses a visual component in his pitches and it’s really effective. As the audience for his practice pitches, I find it very effective. I do it with directing sometimes because I think that’s much more you’re trying to be specific about your vision for this. We did a visual component when we did our final pitch out of the season before we went into production and our production plan.
That was when Lisa Troldenko and Fred Elms would come on. They had how we were going to aesthetically deal with some of these things. It’s just words. Then at the end, we were like, NL Fanning will star on it, so you should buy it.

John: That was about it. You should buy it. Absolutely. Star of one of your other big series. Now, Meriwether, for you, it was already set up at Hulu and you had a star. You had Kate McKinnon attached. It sounds like you actually brought in writers to help you from the start. Is that correct?

Liz Meriwether: It was really bizarre. Also, having now sold it, my next project is a limited series. This, I did it in a more traditional way. I’m realizing how strange that was. I came in and they were just anxious to get going. I sort of had a conversation with Hulu. It was the classic Hollywood thing where they don’t tell you it’s a pitch. They don’t tell you it’s-

Liz Hannah: It’s a meeting. It’s just a meeting. There’s no pressure.

Liz Meriwether: No pressure. It’s a meeting. You would think I would know at this point, but I had notes on my computer. I’d actually had an idea for what the structure was going to be. I pitched them the loose structure of what the episodes were. Then we just got a room together and we started working on it. I think before the room began, I wrote out some document. I don’t remember what it was, but I think it was an overview of what the series was going to be and what each episode roughly was going to be. At that point, I thought it was six episodes, so it wasn’t the most accurate thing.

Liz Hannah: Yes, I mean- I think the pilot. The pilot, it was there. When we walked-

Liz Meriwether: I’d outlined it, right?

Liz Hannah: Yes. You had outlined the pilot. Then there was a few pages of what each episode then was going to be. A lot of how we would break that show in particular were by years because it was so much time had passed. It was like, this episode is between X and X years or X and X month. Then here’s everything that happens in that and that’s what we’ll address. Then going into the room, it was the weaning of that and finding where the story was.

Liz Meriwether: We had that overview and it was like, I was used to getting into the breaking. Then we just had- we realized that we had to do so much research [chuckles]. We had to learn how to do- we had to become engineers and chemists and talk to a bunch of people. The crazy thing was, I was simultaneously- because they were in a hurry to get it out, joke was on them ultimately [laughs]. I was simultaneously running an ABC sitcom called Bless This Mess that was about a young couple on a farm. I had the two rooms going at the same time.

Liz Hannah: On the same- we were on different sides of an office. It was one side of windows and then the other side of windows.

John: It’s basically, yes. Who gets Meriwether’s attention at this moment and you’re trying to pitch the wrong-

Liz Meriwether: I was running back and forth. It was the most strange reality of walking into one room and having conversations about chickens-

Liz Hannah: Microfluidity.

Liz Meriwether: -and chicken comedy. How many chickens? The call sheet for Bless This Mess would sometimes be four goats and having those conversations. Then going into The Dropout room, we were having very serious conversations about sexual assault, and microfluidics and a lot of things-

John: These were actual rooms. This is also a difference because this is pre-pandemic. You were literally together with bodies around the table figuring out this stuff, looking at the same whiteboard experience, which is not norm anymore. That’s all changed.

Liz Meriwether: I think we had an awkward mixer, right? Where it was like the Bless This Mess writers.

Liz Hannah: Yes, we had like a- it was like stepkids meeting for the first time. It was very strange. I think they made- isn’t Cheaper by the Dozen about that? I think that was based on that lunch. Yes, we didn’t have that for Plainville.

John: Let’s talk about the differences between the Plainville room and this room. It feels like-

Liz Meriwether: Do we have to?
[laughter]

John: Well, the Plainville room, you had a pilot already. You were hiring writers to come in to help you out on that. Everyone could look at the same mastered plan. This is the pilot. This is the show we’re trying to make. Then what was the process of figuring out from there how to break out this information across these episodes? What was the- had you done this before?

Liz Hannah: I hadn’t showrun before. No. I was coming in-

John: What was your approach?

Liz Hannah: Fear, terror, a sense of humor about myself. Yes, but is what I would say about the pilot because we had the pilot written, but the pilot is extremely different than the rest of the show because it doesn’t- Conrad is not introduced. His timeline is not introduced until episode two. The prosecution doesn’t begin until episode three. The real investigation doesn’t begin until episode three. The pilot we had, and we had that for a total touchstone and pacing, but we were looking for writers. Patrick was about to go do Dr. Death, and he had just wrapped the writers room for that around the time we’d done the dropout.
There were a few writers on that I met with and really loved and wanted to bring on, and there was a continuity to it, particularly because Patrick was going to production on Death five or six weeks into the room. The big thing for me about all the writers that came in was I wanted writers that didn’t want to write a good true crime story. I wanted writers who didn’t have an interest in just being a straightforward true crime story. I wanted them to come in and do different things, which was similar to The Dropout, if not the same. I don’t think any of us had any interest.
I don’t think anybody had really done true crime except sort of me with Mindhunter, but that doesn’t really count. There were a lot of playwrights in the room. Heldens, who’s the best, she’s the best of the Liz’s, had done network dramas for a long time.

Liz Meriwether: Friday Night Lights.

Liz Hannah: Friday Night Lights. We had talks about that because we were obsessed with Friday Night Lights. I think I played it cool for two days and then was like, “Can we just talk about Friday Night Lights?” It was like we all approached it from a very different way. Then Heldens would be like, this is how a show is written. We were like, copy. [laughs] That was the approach that I took to Plainville. It was just having a bunch of interesting brains, not necessarily brains that were experienced in writing this material. We knew similarly with the structure, what we were talking about before, we knew that the final episode was going to be, I actually think we thought the penultimate episode was going to be Coco’s last day.
Then ultimately, as we got into the break, we realized it was going to be the last episode. Then we had the spine of the investigation and the trial and things like that. I would say the biggest obstacle we had is that nobody was interested in the trial. We were like, “We’ve seen it.” It was similar with Elizabeth where at a certain point we were like, we’ve reached this place where everybody knows her. How do you make it interesting? Everybody’s seen this part from documentaries.
I would say the trial and the breaking of that was by far the most difficult part of the process because we were hamstrung into making it, you have to tell the facts and you have to tell the story that I think is fascinating. It was like, “How did this girl get convicted off of something she said that we don’t know if she said?” Based on a text message to another friend, it’s a very flimsy thing to be convicted on. That was fascinating to me. We’ve also seen trials before. How do you make it interesting?

John: Now, Meriwether, for something like New Girl, you are breaking story, you are shooting an episode, you’re writing an episode, you’re shooting an episode, you are posting an episode all at the same time. How different was it going from that to this where you went into production with these scripts written? It felt like you were doing one thing at a time.

Liz Meriwether: Is that what you think happened? [laughs]

John: Were there things that you would do differently based on what you’ve learned [crosstalk]?

Liz Meriwether: I learned an important thing, which is that I can’t run two shows at the same time. I certainly can’t-

John: I love [unintelligible 00:37:30].

Liz Meriwether: -run a show on network that’s airing at the same time that I’m running another show because the way you describe my job on New Girl was my job on Bless This Mess too. We’re shooting, editing, and writing. Then I was also running this other thing. At a certain point, I think I just couldn’t. I couldn’t anymore. It was too hard. I really am in awe of those showrunners that can do that. It was an important step for me to realize that I can’t. I’ll never put myself in that situation again. I think that-

John: I don’t think I could run a show that was- I couldn’t do what you did on New Girl where you’re running a show that’s airing right now.

Liz Meriwether: I couldn’t do it either.

John: You did it for seven seasons, by the way. You did it for seven seasons.

Liz Meriwether: Yes, I had a lot of help. It’s very hard, and it’s not conducive to great television.

John: Or good life or happiness.

Liz Hannah: Yes, it’s not conducive to life.

Liz Meriwether: Yes. I didn’t have kids when I was on New Girl. Yes, I spent nights at the office. It was my entire life. It consumed my whole life. It’s just not a good way to work. I hope that- I was so happy with all the iotsy stories, and I was reading all of the- I do feel like a lot of the way that television gets made needs to adjust a little bit.

John: Now, was this experience on The Dropout better in that way in terms of doing one thing at a time? What were the pros and what were the cons? I definitely heard a lot of the cons, which is that sometimes the writing process is so divorced by months or by a year from the production process that people end up being dragged across- a producer, in your case, could be still producing a show that they wrote a year ago, and they’re not getting paid any more money, and they’re actually being pushed down towards scale levels of pay because they’re still producing this thing or the original writers can’t be involved with the actual production because they’re now on three shows after this.
Those are some of the cons.

Liz Meriwether: The writers removed Dropout. I was doing a bunch of things at the same time, but we weren’t shooting it. That was different. I think the system hurts the younger writers the most because I feel like working on New Girl was this amazing crash course for a lot of people, including myself, on television production. I think it’s so important and so great to see an episode from start to finish. Even if it gets rewritten a million times. To be able to go to the table where you hear what the notes are, hear how the showrunner handles the notes, go to set, all those things are invaluable.
It’s, honestly, in a job that doesn’t have really a school that you can go to figure out. That is what the school is. I think it made me sad that the writers on The Dropout weren’t involved in the production at all. It was like I was texting Hannah screenshots of the monitor, and I was like, this is your episode. I really didn’t like that way of working it. I felt like that was strange.

Liz Hannah: COVID on top of it, you can’t bring, or at least for us, we couldn’t bring our writers to set. Even if you can’t, because now it’s just so rare to have the writer who wrote the episode cover the episode, or even be a part of it. Even pre-COVID, I agree, it’s just not a typical thing anymore.

Liz Meriwether: I felt guilty, because I was like, well, you’re not being paid anymore. I can’t ask you to be on set. This is just crazy.

Liz Hannah: Yes, when it’s disconnected like that, you’re still not in the writer’s room. It’s been so much time. What’s the incentive to do it other than the learning experience? I think it’s really important for everyone to, if they can, just go visit for a couple of days and be on set and observe and be a part of it and because of COVID, we couldn’t do that for any of our writers. We couldn’t do it for any of our support staff, because we were on lockdown. I think Dropout wrapped before us, because we were, we started prep in June and we wrapped in the middle of December. We were really fortunate to bridge both Delta and Omicron.
We were PCR testing every single day until two weeks after Thanksgiving. Then we were PCR testing three days a week. Then we got hit by Omicron two days before we wrapped. I turned to Dan Minahan, the director, and I was like, “Dan, I have to leave. I have to leave here. You have to finish this episode of television before 2022. We have to finish it.” He was like, “There’s no one left to do the show.” I was like, “I don’t care. It’ll be you and me.” I agree. I think it’s a real bummer that writers, because being a writer in television is 30% of the job. Being a writer as a showrunner is 15% of the job. There’s so much more to it. If you’re not exposed to it, you have no idea.

Liz Meriwether: I will say the pro for me was after the room was finished and because we had COVID. I had a year to sit with the scripts. It was the first time in my life. When I was writing for theater, I had the same time. That part of it was incredible. I just could sit with the scripts and think. I had nothing else to do. It was like, I just got to write. What a gift. That’s great. I think once we started production, when you’re making network television, you’re getting constant feedback.
Sometimes it’s great to incorporate that into the show. Sometimes it can be destructive because you’re chasing numbers or you read a Tweet and then you change a whole storyline. I think when you’re making network television, you have to protect yourself a little bit of that. I was scared because I was like, we’re not seeing anything. I’m not seeing anything. I don’t have any feedback. I don’t have any audience. I just have to keep going down this road. That part of it was a little unnerving too.
This is a very long answer to your question. I think for me, it was a lot of pros and cons in interesting ways. I feel like I learned a lot from doing it.

John: Let’s wrap up this pros and cons with our fantasy world because you’re both people who’ve successfully run these limited series now. If you could set it up in your dream way, what would you do differently or how would it work? Is there a way to get those writers on the set? Is there a way to make sure that we could actually have that apprenticeship that you learned? The good thing about New Girl, is there any stuff that you could bring through to this process or Hannah from Futures, is there stuff that we could be doing that would make these even better?

Liz Hannah: I’m laughing just because I’m like, “I really just wanted more time and money and [laughs] not having to-

John: A unique thing, yes.

Liz Hannah: The COVID situation was really detrimental, I think, to everybody. Obviously, everybody in the world, but I think to filmmaking and to television was really detrimental. There was just so much that was impacted creatively in the show that was really a bummer and that bums me out. More time and money, please. I take it here. Thank you.

John: Structurally, is there a way to make the experience of doing these shows better for writers and ultimately for the better to create a project at the end? I’m just thinking ahead. If people who are setting up these shows now, what kinds of things could they ask for that would make it a better process for them as showrunners, but also for their staff?

Liz Hannah: I was going to say, I do think it has to do with money, which is making it part of your budget that you’re bringing the writer to set. I also think it’s a part of talking about how we make these shows, which is, Meriweather you do this, and I know some other showrunners that do this, but not a lot of people do this. You talk about the showrunner, you don’t talk about the room. Normalizing the fact that television is not made by one singular person, that it’s a group of people that make it. It’s similar to talking about being rewritten in features. When you’re rewritten in features, the first time it happens, you’re like, “What? This never happened. How is this happening?”
Then you talk to a feature writer and you’re like, oh, no, this happens on every single script. It will happen to you for the rest of your career. It does not matter how big you are, how little you are. It will happen forever. You have to just have conversations about it. There’s a good way to do it and a bad way to do it. We’ve talked about that before, of if you’re the rewriter reaching out to the person you’re rewriting, however it is. I think that having a larger conversation of like, this episode was written by this person, and this is the person who came up with this, and there’s enough credit to go around.
The only way that I think networks and studios will find it important to bring those people to set and empower them is if we empower them and we’re like, we can’t do this without them, they know this. I was really fortunate to bring my number two in the room, Ashley Michael Hoban, to set. I was like, “I’ve never run a show before.” Patrick’s, it was in post on Death, I think, and then it was airing, and I’m not doing this by myself. That’s a really quick way for me to lose my mind and for this to be a terrible show. Hoban was there the entire run of the show and covered set, and it was amazing.
I literally would not have survived without her, and the show would have not been good without her. I just think that took just convincing. Anyways, I just think there’s enough credit to go around that we should just be like, “These are the people who need to be here to make it better.” You hire 9,000 PAs because we can’t do these things ourselves. It’s not dissimilar to, we need writers around to make this better.

John: Now, let’s talk about the writer’s responsibility on the set because I’m sure it varies from project to project. Liz, you were covering set sometimes. You also had someone else helping you there, [unintelligible 00:47:18] Hannah. Meriwether, were you on set for the whole thing? What were your responsibilities on a day of shooting?

Liz Meriwether: For your listeners who are going to hear the bonus content, I just recently given birth. I know that I gave birth on April the 10th, which is my son’s birthday, and we started shooting in June. I had an infant and also COVID, so I was on a feed, which was, for me, it’s so hard.

Liz Hannah: It’s horrible, it’s awful.

Liz Meriwether: I really felt for the director and trying to text notes that are complicated, that are like, “Can she move her?” Putting that over text messages is crazy. I didn’t have a room anymore. Everything that Hannah just said was brilliant and exactly right. I loved the script coordinator who had been with me for the year after we had the room, Zach Benozzo, who I asked to be on set. I just promoted him to associate producer. He was on set every day. He had a really tough job of me texting him and him having to go and give notes to the director, who’s occasionally not psyched that there was a dude here shoving a phone in his face.

Liz Hannah: To be fair, they’re not always psyched when it’s you approaching them without the phone.

Liz Meriwether: That was really hard. That being said, I also am glad I wasn’t there at every moment. I feel like on New Girl, sometimes when we got behind, I was always trying to fix things on set or fix story issues or character stuff on set. I liked having a little distance, I think, in the end because I don’t know how to direct a drama. I think it was good that I was on this couch in a weird little bubble, looking at a feed, pumping milk out of my breasts. It’s a very weird existence.

John: Hannah, what were you doing?

Liz Hannah: I was on location the whole time. We all moved to Savannah from June to December. My husband and I drove across the country with our dog. Similarly, the day after we arrived in Savannah, I found out I was pregnant, which was not a plan that we had. That was a bit of a twist. I was pregnant the entire time we were shooting. By the time we wrapped, I was seven and a half months pregnant. I was on set in Savannah in the summer. We’ll talk about it for the bonus. It’s great.

John: Obviously, as the writer covering set, you’re there to make sure that the scene is actually doing what you need it to do. You’re there as a second set of eyes and whispering to the director and getting stuff moved, but were you also rewriting or changing things? How much changed on the day?

Liz Hannah: Quite a lot. Not on the day necessarily, but there was a lot that changed before we went into production and prep. Patrick was there for prep, Ashley Michael was there for prep, I was there, and then our producing partner, Brittany Kahan Ward, was there. Brittany basically [chuckles] body-blocked people from coming into our offices so we could write. We had seven of eight written. Patrick and I wrote, I think, during prep. We turned in the first draft.
Then I think our shortest script was 57 pages when we flew to Savannah or when we got to Savannah. That was exceptionally long. They all had to be cut. I think every script got cut between 7 and 11 pages. That was just a massive overhaul that we had to do to begin with, something that I really liked to do that we’d done in the room but hadn’t been able to do with all the episodes because obviously seven and eight weren’t written.
We’d done this on Mindhunter. We pulled character storylines and put them in a final draft document and treated them almost like they were features. We would have 400 pages of Wendy and would be like, “How does she flow through the season?” Then you put them back in and see how they speak to each other.

Liz Meriwether: Oh, that’s so cool. That’s such a good idea.

Liz Hannah: It was Courtenay Miles on Mindhunter, and Fincher were like, “Can you take this character and do this?” I was like, “Yes.” Again, it was one of those things where I’m like, “That actually sounds like something that’s common sense to do,” and I’d never done it. I’d never done it for a feature either, just taking character and being like, “Here are these scenes.” We did that in Plainville with Michelle in particular because her arc is so circular in that if you watch the past timeline in the finale and then you watch the present timeline in the pilot, you’re fully caught up. It’s like there’s one hour that’s been skipped, basically. We were able to do that and spend time on that.
Then once a director and a cinematographer come on, this process was not super dissimilar from features in terms of Lisa and Fred were there for prep for a good amount of time and were very involved in how we were going to tell a lot of these stories. We did, I think, four tone meetings for one and three and were really drilling down on it. That’s what we were doing for all the prep. Then I covered for one and three. Then Ashley Michael and Patrick did two, and she covered me when I was directing. She also covered four and five. I would prep while they were covering. We basically just did that until [crosstalk] we lost time, and now we’re here.

Liz Meriwether: I always think a writer on set, though; what I always found was so amazing about it was that they had this breadth of knowledge. They knew what every joke was supposed to be and why it was there. To me, it was like this person who could speak to the choices that we had made in the writers’ room. I did feel the lack of that in not having the writer on set.

Liz Hannah: It’s like an encyclopedia.

Liz Meriwether: Yes, it’s an encyclopedia of what happened in the writers’ room, which I think is really important. Similarly, because of the situation, I had marathon-length meetings that show author, I think, is still scarred from– [chuckles] I think we were averaging about four hours an episode, which is pretty embarrassing.

Liz Hannah: Yes, but very detailed.

Liz Meriwether: I felt like I was just going to have to really get to say everything. It actually did help. I think, in the end, a lot of rewrites came from the tone meeting of just talking stuff through. I wasn’t actually doing that much rewriting on set, which was really helpful. I went into production not having written– I had a first draft of seven, and I had not written eight at all. I don’t recommend that.

Liz Hannah: Yes. Having to write eight while we were in production was brutal. This was the first time I was a director, and I was covered on set, which was a fascinating experience. I was like, “I’ll be fine. I don’t need a writer to cover me. Of the two, I wrote one of them. It’ll be fine.” Then I got three days into production. I turned to Brittany, and I was like, “I think I need Ashley Michael to come back.” She’s like, “She’s coming back on Friday.

Liz Meriwether: You need it, yes.

Liz Hannah: It sounds silly because it’s like, “Oh, you wrote the episode. You’re the showrunner. Why do you need a writer there?” It’s like, because as the director, you’re not thinking about it.

Liz Meriwether: [unintelligible 00:54:41]

Liz Hannah: Yes. I don’t want to rewrite while I’m also trying to convey to an actor what the interpretation of the material is. I don’t want to have to figure out why the scene is not working in real life when it worked on the page while we have 10 hours to shoot. Then also having a producer on set- that’s the other thing. It’s like I was the producer on set when I wasn’t just the writer on set.
There were things that would happen that I was like, “I, as the writer and director, now cannot be the producer.” You can’t wear all of the hats at once as much as you want to. I was extraordinarily pregnant at that point and barely mobile. I think, if anything, it doubled down the need for writers to be on set for features, for TV, for everything. Having another set of eyes, it’s the best gift you could have. I don’t know why you wouldn’t want it.

Flashback: On Set, Legal, and Ethics

↑ Back to Top
John: A couple of terms that have come up here that I want to make sure we’re talking through. A tone meeting for the two of you is really walking through the script with the director or other important department heads in terms of this is what’s happening in the scene, this is what it needs to be, to make sure you’re not getting the wrong version of the scene at the end of the day. What else is important to cover in a tone meeting?

Liz Hannah: Any questions they have or anything they don’t understand. That’s usually the first tone meeting, is usually when you get a lot of the notes from them. We did multiple tone meetings for every episode because it was just a bananas show, and there was a lot of confusing about it. We would do that. Then it’s really you go through every line of dialogue, every choice a character makes, every moment of the show.

Liz Meriwether: It’s supposed to be your chance to talk to the director. In an ideal world, it’s like this is your version of communicating to the director how you would want it directed, I guess. On New Girl, once we were in production, the tone meeting, unfortunately, became my first real actually engaging with the director on an episode. A lot of the time, our amazing line producer, Erin O’Malley, got the rhythm of that. While she was prepping with the director, she would know that things would pop up, and she’d text me like, “He’s doing this,” or, “She’s doing it,” because there were certainly times when we would get to tone meeting, and I’d be like, “Wait, that’s completely lost.”

John: That sounds [unintelligible 00:57:06].

Liz Meriwether: Usually, the tone meetings are set for the Friday before you start shooting on Monday when you’re doing network. That’s too late to make big changes. It was trying to get ahead of that. We started calling them pre-tone meetings, and then it was like they were taking so long that they just became the tone meeting because nobody was going to do a pre-tone meeting and end-of-tone meeting.
All of the designers started listening in just because so much comes up. For us in the dropout, they became a concept meeting and a tone meeting where it was talking through what everything was going to be. Television is supposed to be pretty organized with meetings and production and stuff, but I think doing limited series and things, people are making different rules and what works for them a little bit more.

John: You’re halfway between how a feature would do things and how a normal series would do things because, in both of your shows, you had some sets you could come back to. Were either of your shows block shot, or did you shoot episode by episode?

Liz Hannah: Yes.

Liz Meriwether: Yes.

John: You were block shooting. Defining terms, in block shooting, you can group together all of an actor’s scenes or all of a set that you’re going to use that appears in multiple episodes, so you can efficiently shoot that out and then move on to the next thing. It’s always a question of how to best– [crosstalk] That’s fine.

Liz Hannah: I had never done that before because for network, you don’t really block shoot because the stuff is just not ready with enough time to block shoot. We block shot the dropout episodes one through four.

John: Wow.

Liz Hannah: Prepping for four drama episodes at the same time, it was–

Liz Meriwether: When you told me that, because you sent me a photo from Old White Guys in August and I was like, “You guys are already on episode four?” and you’re like, “We’re block shooting four episodes,” I was like, “That’s terrible.” What a nightmare. I can’t believe you guys did that.

Liz Hannah: Keeping it all in your head where you’re like, “Oh God, wait, that’s a scene in episode four.” Then after that, we did two. It’s two at a time.

Liz Meriwether: We did two at a time, and then we had two solos. Two and eight were single episodes.

John: Generally, in block shooting, you’d have the same director and cinematographer who’d be working on those things so they could collaborate on that.

Liz Hannah: Yes, we had AD team swap it, going back and forth. Just going back to the tone meeting really quick because I also toned six and seven with Patrick, which was a funny experience. When you have a co-showrunner, there’s also a funny experience. It’s like, “Who’s going to blink first on what they want to say the scene is about, to see if they’re wrong?” Because he and I would split scenes, and then we’d do passes on each other’s scenes. I think with seven that we were talking about something, and we were just like, “What do you think this should be about? How should we do this?” It’s a fun experience. I encourage everybody to do.

John: It’s nice. Let’s wrap up this conversation and talk about stories based on true events. These people are still alive. These are people who could come after and sue producers and stuff. At what point were there conversations with legal departments about, like, “These are things we can do, the things that we can say or can’t say”?

Liz Hannah: Constant. All the time.

Liz Meriwether: Yes, all the time.

John: You’re going to have to make choices about how you’re portraying these events, and there’s certain things which are going to be easily factually documentable, and these text messages happened or didn’t happen, and there’s going to be things which you are inventing because you are inventing a show. At what stage did legal get involved? How early did it happen? How much does it factor in the story you ended up being able to tell? Let’s start with Girl From Plainville. Obviously, the trial had happened. There’s documentation about a lot of stuff, but as I watch the show, there is an opening credit thing saying, “This is based on real events, but they’re fictional things.” What was the conversation?

Liz Hannah: The short conversation is that we talked to legal, I think, before we even sold the show. I think we talked to legal when we were writing the pilot. There were a number of things, not the least of which was Glee, that we knew had to be in the show. We didn’t get the okay to use Glee until four weeks before the show premiered. There was a lot that [chuckles] there were Plan Bs on. That was a constant conversation.

Liz Meriwether: That’s crazy. Sorry.

Liz Hannah: We had the okay to do Make You Feel My Love when we shot it, but we reshot that in December. That was originally shot with the way that you could cut, basically, seeing Glee out or only use fair use, which is about three to five seconds. Then you really get into it, and it’s two and a half seconds, which meant nothing. We had that version, and it just did not work. The whole point was to see it. Patrick spoke to our partners at Hulu, and then we all got on the phone with everybody, and we’re like, “We want to reshoot it, but we don’t want to reshoot it unless we can use Glee.” We got that. We were in our last week of shooting. [crosstalk] Early December probably.
Then we didn’t get the rights to do the rest of Glee until right before it premiered. We were constantly talking to legal. Then, because we had the text messages, the one thing I really learned from the dropout that I brought onto this show was having a dedicated researcher, hiring somebody specifically to be a researcher, because there was so much more than even we thought we would need to know in the dropout, and then very quickly realized I have no idea what microfluidics still is. I think once I could write a sentence about it, and it maybe was accurate, but it’s gone now.

Liz Meriwether: Tiny fluids.

Liz Hannah: I know that.

John: Teeny-tiny fluids.

Liz Hannah: We had somebody draw a diagram of the box for us on a whiteboard because we did not understand it. By the way, it didn’t work, so there’s a reason we didn’t understand it, but it was very confusing to us. I hired a dedicated researcher named Padraic Murphy, who’s incredible. He came on very soon at the beginning and made all the text messages searchable for us and made them consumable so that it wasn’t just literally scrolling through text.
Then that was given to our lawyers at the studio, so that they could vet every script. Every text message conversation in the show is either exactly the conversation they had or a paraphrase for Time, or they were like, “Hurt you,” things like that. It was constant. Then we changed the names of anybody who was underage during the show, except for Conrad and Michelle.

Liz Meriwether: I, obviously, never worked with a lawyer on anything that I’d ever written.

John: Because New Girl wasn’t going to libel anybody.

Liz Meriwether: No.

John: New Girl was going to say, “Happy reality, yes.”

Liz Meriwether: It was interesting because I think at first I was really thrown by it. I think that we started having conversations with legal as soon as we started turning material in. Hannah was there for a lot of it, but it was just so exhaustive. Just every tiny thing, and our amazing writers’ assistants and script coordinators having to answer a lot of these legal emails and things with our research and being able to-

Liz Hannah: Annotations, yes.

Liz Meriwether: -back it up and annotations. Yes. Then I think at a certain point, I started really appreciating the conversation. I started thinking about it, like, it’s keeping you honest in many ways, but as a writer, you can get really caught up in the story and just trying to tell it in the best way that you think. Often, the real story has nuances and gray areas and just contradictions that are interesting. I think it definitely was frustrating at times, but then other times I feel like it veered us in better directions than it would have otherwise.
The other thing about legal notes is sometimes they sound really big. They sound really global. There’s really scary legal language where it’s defamation and all this. Then when you get down to it, it’s like, “Can you change this glass to a plastic cup?”

Liz Hannah: I was going to say that was-

Liz Meriwether: That was one particular example.

Liz Hannah: -one of my favorite legal conversations to use as an example in the room where I’m like, “When you get this note, this is how you can do it,” which is there’s a scene in the show where it’s in the trailer, but I don’t think it’s in the show, which is funny.

Liz Meriwether: Oh.

Liz Hannah: Sunny was going to throw a glass at Elizabeth, and it was the green juice, and it shattered on the wall. [chuckles] It was a 20 to 30-minute conversation about this glass and what it could mean.

John: A glass that shattered would be dangerous, whereas a plastic cup is not as– [crosstalk]

Liz Hannah: Yes. Meriwether was like, “What if it’s plastic?” They were like, “Yes, totally, that would work.” We were like, “That’s 20 minutes of our lives that we’ll never get back.” Again, it makes sense, and you know why they’re doing it. They’re doing their job. That’s why they have their job, and I don’t. When you break it down to that minimal sort of a thing, and you’re very stressed out about being sued, it’s–

Liz Meriwether: Beyond being stressed out about being sued, I felt, and I’m sure Hannah felt this, too, just an enormous responsibility. I felt like I thought about it constantly. It was something that I was constantly worried about.

John: Meriwether, there’s legal, and there’s ethical. You’re telling a story, and some of these people will not have their own chance to tell the story. You’re going to be the public representation of what they were thinking, what they were doing.
I think at your show, Hannah, about the ethical and moral responsibilities of portraying teen suicide, while there’s a warning card and there’s all this stuff and there’s resources available, it must have been a constant discussion about how are we going to responsibly portray this real thing that happened in a way that’s interesting, but it’s not going to be glamorizing– What were some of the conversations you had about that, and who else did you involve in those conversations?

Liz Hannah: There was a lot of conversation about that before we even agreed to do the show because it was like, “Is this the right thing to do? Does this need to exist?” Ultimately, I do think it does, again, for what we were talking about, that I think it can hopefully be additive to a conversation about the three-dimensionality of mental health, that mental health is health and we should talk about it.
That I think, with Coco in particular, and to some extent, Michelle, that his suicide was so abrupt and shocking to his family, and who he was with Michelle was not the person that he was with everyone else, and that also he had a really good day the day before he died, or he had a really good morning the day of his death. That that suicidal ideation and depression is not a contiguous line, and it’s not a straight line. It’s a roller coaster. You get flipped upside down, and you go backwards and forwards.
Not just expecting somebody who’s depressed to present as depressed, I think, was a conversation that we’ve been having for a long time. I thought that this show could help be additive in that conversation and in that depiction. Also, I’m not a mental health worker. I don’t have any experience in that. We brought on the American Foundation for Suicide Prevention, which was the foundation we’d worked with on Bright Places as well.
Their team read every outline and read every script, and they watched the cuts. They were extremely additive in avoiding triggers or being aware of triggers. Conrad dies by suicide in the show. That was something that obviously is going to have to happen in the show. Being able to tell that in a way that doesn’t feel grotesque or gratuitous or horrific or any of those things was extremely important to us that we were telling it responsibly.

Liz Meriwether: I thought you did that so well in the pilot with them.

Liz Hannah: Thank you.

Liz Meriwether: Discovering his body. I loved that the camera stayed on the police officer and that you just were getting the information that you needed. I think there’s obviously a lot that is done in the writing, but it should be such a conversation with the director and how things are being shot and the way that they’re being represented.

Liz Hannah: I think all of our directors met with AFSP to have those conversations as well. That in particular was something that we talked to them about. We never show his body on the show in that way. Obviously, we have images of it or glimpses of it, but that was quite gratuitous to me in particular and to Patrick. We didn’t want to do that. Something that I learned on the show that I never knew before, and I’d made a movie that dealt with similar issues, was that the terminology or the phrasing of it is died by suicide because committed puts the blame and ownness on the person who’s suffering, and that depression that leads to suicide is like cancer.
It’s like taking the blame off of that person, which for me was a revelation and was really, honestly, which was our very first conversation with AFSP, that very small– Then they corrected me. They were like, “Hey, just so you know, this is how we talk about it.” That really actually opened up the whole conversation of Conrad’s journey and trying to be respectful. I absolutely live in fear that the thing I don’t want to do is ever make somebody feel not seen because of the show or because of something that we were trying to say, and feel ignored or that we did something salacious or anything like that. We really actively tried to avoid that at all times.

John: Even thinking about that moment where the body is discovered, we stay with Norbert Leo Butz’s character who calls to say there’s yellow tape everywhere. It doesn’t even say death. It’s just that it’s about the moment and the situation and not the evaluation of what’s happened there.

Liz Hannah: Going to what Meriwether said, that’s actually what Co said to Lynn, in that truth is stranger than fiction, or more emotional than fiction. Everything that happens in the pilot is something that was sourced. A lot of the conversation were things that we got from court transcripts or interviews. Jesse Barron had done a lot of interviews and had a lot of material that couldn’t make it into the Esquire article that we had.
Lynn, in particular, for me, is somebody that I felt an enormous amount of responsibility for in telling her story. She was actually the reason I leaned into the show in a lot of ways. I love her. I think she’s such a fascinating woman. The way she speaks is so eloquent, and what she’s gone through is horrific. I feel a real responsibility, of course.

Flashback: Pitching the Next True Story

↑ Back to Top
John: Great. Now, we’ve had a long conversation about some of the shows you’ve made. I don’t think we have time to do a big, deep dive on how these other things be a movie, but I want to hit the headlines here. We’ll put links in the show notes for what we were going to talk about more fully, but maybe we can vote on which of these three things is most interesting for you guys to pitch as a future limited series.
The first one we want to talk through was Birds Aren’t Real, which is early 2017. Peter McIndoe was studying psychology at the University of Alabama. He went to a protest. He wanted to be a counter-protester and held up a sign called Birds Aren’t Real, which was just a joke, but he became an improver who was going on this whole big fake conspiracy about birds not being real. My teenage daughter loves it. I think it’s a great meme. Is there a story to be told about Birds Aren’t Real?

Liz Hannah: Yes. [chuckles]

John: Either Elle or Liz, do you think there’s something to be made there?

Liz Hannah: I’m trying to pull up the– Maybe I won’t, because it’s actually my One Cool Thing is this article, so I won’t say it. I would say that there’s something to be made about the society that does that, that we’re the society that, two years ago, one of the most famous NBA stars in the league is like, “The Earth is flat.” That’s where we’re at in our space.

John: I feel like it’s such an amazing story about young people, too. That part of it really jumps out at me as just what it feels like to be a young person right now, where you’re living in this absurd time and it coming out in that absurd way. That feels really funny to me, or you lean in, and you just do a documentary about how birds are real, as if you’re explaining birds to somebody.

Liz Hannah: It’s The Pelican Brief. We actually watch the documentary.

John: We love it.

Liz Meriwether: That’s such a dad joke.

Liz Hannah: I know. You’re welcome. It happens now.

John: I do also love that he’s homeschooled and he says that that’s a big part of how he has this feeling about being raised in the bubble of homeschooling and a very Christian upbringing. It’s interesting. Now, you both made a great series about young blonde women who are the center of a story in which mental health becomes a big thing. Let’s talk about the Britney Spears conservatorship and the end of the Britney Spears conservatorship. What is the series we might make about Britney Spears?
One of the things we always are wrestling with when Craig’s on the show with us is: where do you start and where do you end the story? Is there a story to be made about the conservatorship and her being trapped in this and breaking free of it? Do you start the story earlier? What kind of Britney Spears limited series would be interesting to make?

Liz Hannah: I’m just laughing because I feel like I’m going to end up making this show because Elle and I recently discovered I’ve only worked with blonde actresses in my career. I’m just going to make another blonde story.

Liz Meriwether: The gaslighting part of it is really interesting to me. I think the experience of realizing that you’re trapped in this thing, the story that really jumped out at me about all of it was putting a bug in her room, that her dad put a bug in her room. Just the feeling of safety with the family and then slowly realizing that that family is against you, I think, is fascinating. I feel like that would be what I would focus on, as long as you could have a lot of big musical numbers, I guess.

Liz Hannah: Yes, obviously. The thing that makes me the saddest of that story is that Britney did need help. She needed help. She needed somebody to help her get out of a very dark place, and that they took advantage of her in that way. She still didn’t get help. That’s the part that ultimately is so tragic to me, is that she didn’t get what was the only thing she needed and the way we talk about mental health, and particularly women, and maybe just because I had a baby, but postpartum.
The thing that sticks with me that she talked about was her sitting in that restaurant with her two kids because the paparazzi were outside, and nobody would help her, and everyone was making fun of her in that restaurant. That’s horrific. I’m not Britney Spears, and I could not imagine my child having a meltdown and everyone being horrible to me in a crowded place. I find that so tragic.

Liz Meriwether: That’s interesting. Would you start the story there, and it’s a rock and a hard place? It’s like she’s either going to be out in public on her own and totally under attack, or she’s going to be in her family, where she thinks is safe is actually-

Liz Hannah: The complete opposite.

Liz Meriwether: -against her. I think that’s fascinating. I don’t know. I had my agent, who’s no longer my agent, early on when I started writing. I was talking to him about wanting to go to therapy, and he was like, “No, don’t go to therapy. I need you to keep writing, keep making scripts.” He was joking, but I think that mindset of just keep producing–

Liz Hannah: Yes, and don’t take care of yourself.

Liz Meriwether: Yes. That part of it’s interesting. I also love that in the Britney Spears story, that Instagram becomes this outlet for her is fascinating.

Liz Hannah: I’m really into this. [chuckles] Should we do it?

John: By the time this episode comes out, you guys can set this up. I feel like it should be together. [crosstalk]

Liz Meriwether: I do think that question of would we need that; her story has been taken from her so many times. It would be very interesting because I think, at this point, she needs to tell her own story, I feel.

John: Finally, Mackenzie Bezos Scott. I only knew her as Jeff Bezos’s ex-wife who has been giving away all her money. I wasn’t clear on her backstory. She actually has a really interesting backstory. In some ways, it reminds me of The Dropout, Elizabeth Holmes, in that she grew up with a lot of money. All the money went away. She struggled to get through her writing degree.

Liz Hannah: She had to leave high school because they couldn’t pay for school, right?

John: Then ends up becoming quite a good writer and then being with Jeff Bezos and helping him start Amazon. She was a much more interesting character. Now, I have to say she has dark hair. That may just rule her out from Liz Hannah’s–

Liz Hannah: Oh, Jesus. Didn’t even read the article because of that. I was like, “Ah.”

Liz Meriwether: I did make a show with actors with dark hair for the– [crosstalk]

John: Famously dark hair and bangs.

Liz Hannah: Also, I just want to be clear that I’m a brunette. Let’s not make this a situation. I think it’s funny. That’s all.

John: Is there a Mackenzie Bezos story to be told that is not set around Jeff Bezos? What are you thinking about her as a character at the center of a series? Is there a series to be made there? I’m not sure there is, but tell me what your instinct is.

Liz Meriwether: I love that she’s given away $12 billion. I think about that all the time; just this happening into so much money. I think I would start it in the middle of her marriage or the beginning of the end of the marriage and then just track the experience of getting divorced from the world’s richest man. Then she falls in love with a high school teacher, which I think is amazing. She’s given away more money than anybody else in the world, I think, if I remember.

Liz Hannah: I think in that amount of time.

Liz Meriwether: Yes.

John: With what you’re describing, though, I wonder whether you need to tell the actual real person’s story, or if it’s just an interesting jumping-off place. You could imagine a woman who gets divorced and ends up with a crazy amount of money; it doesn’t have to be billions, but just a crazy amount of money, who then falls in love with the chemistry teacher. That’s an interesting premise in and of itself.

Liz Hannah: I smell a rom-com.

John: Yes. I’m just wondering if it’s a marry-me. I think there’s something more classically comedic about it.

Liz Meriwether: That’s interesting. I don’t know. It’s such a marriage in a couple that I feel like people want to know about. That’s another interesting one because she’s really, really private. I think it would have to be a question if you’d want to invade that privacy.

John: There’s also the possibility of where Succession isn’t technically about the Murdochs.

Liz Meriwether: That’s true.

John: It’s sort of about the Murdochs. Maybe you could do a show that’s not exactly them, but that high-profile divorce is at the center of it.

Liz Meriwether: That’s a great idea, yes.

John: I’ll sell that one.

Liz Hannah: Yes. [chuckles]

John: Divide the three of them up. Hopefully, people will sell–

Liz Meriwether: Ours is about Sydney Beers.

Liz Hannah: [chuckles] I also can’t believe we’ve been talking for 90 minutes and Succession just got brought up and neither of us were the ones that brought it up.

Liz Meriwether: [laughs]

Liz Hannah: That’s-

Liz Meriwether: Hey.

Liz Hannah: -a very interesting twist.

John: Could happen.

Liz Hannah: Didn’t expect it. I love the idea that while Jeff Bezos and Elon Musk are both trying to buy Twitter and flying into outer space, she’s just writing checks for billions of dollars.

John: Through YMCA, yes.

Liz Hannah: It’s the best way to get back on your asshole ex-husband is be a [chuckles] really good person-

John: [chuckles]

Liz Hannah: -and make him look even shittier. It’s amazing.

Liz Meriwether: I also think it’s amazing all she wanted to do was publish a book, and then she ends up [chuckles] in a relationship with the man who’s killing bookstores. Then she can’t sell her–

John: That irony is amazing. Yes.

Liz Meriwether: Maybe you could do an insane First Wives Club with Melinda Gates.

John: Yes.

Liz Meriwether: By the way, I do love true stories. I know there’s probably now too many of them, and we’re going to go in a different direction. My dad is a journalist. I feel like there’s something interesting to me. I do get excited about them.

John: You were describing at the start of the conversation that you want people to tell you what the rules are, what the boundaries are. What’s nice about reality is there’s some boundaries there. That does help that there’s a certain thing to follow.

Liz Meriwether: Having you repeat that back to me was like therapy, and I’m like, “Oh, yes, I do like when-
[laughter]

Liz Meriwether: -people tell me what the rules are.”

Liz Hannah: I also think what you said about the interior life and that giving purpose to a true story is, I think, the important thing. For me, it serves a purpose if you’re telling the interior story. That can’t be told by journalists, or that’s not their job, as you said. I thought that was really smart. I’m also somebody who’s literally made a career doing true stories, so I apologize. So sorry.

John: [chuckles]
[music]

One Cool Thing

↑ Back to Top
John: We are back here in 2026. It is time for our One Cool Things. Craig, my One Cool Thing is I’ve become more aware of implicit rules that native speakers follow that we don’t know that we’re consciously following them. An example I just learned about was ablaut reduplication. We have a tendency in English to repeat a word while changing its vowel in a very specific way. We say tick-tack-toe. We don’t say toe-tack-tick. We say ding-dang-dong, sing-a-song, hip-hop, flip-flop, tip-top, chit-chat, zig-zag. What is the rule there?

Craig: Ih seems to be bigger than ah, which seems to be bigger than uh. Ih, ah, uh. Maybe the more you open your mouth, the later it gets in the sequence.

John: It’s actually how far back in your mouth you’re making the vowel sound. It’s very consistent in English. We will always basically do it that way, and so ih, ah, oh is the– [crosstalk]

Craig: Yes, Bingo, Bango, Bongo.

John: Many languages do the same thing, although some languages will flip it and go from the back of the mouth forward.

Craig: It’s just wrong.

John: Another thing which we do in English, and I’m sure you’re aware of this, is how we order our adjectives. If I say, “A lovely little old red Italian wooden dining table,” that makes sense to us. If I remove any of those words in a different order, it sounds wrong. A round little red Italian lovely wooden dining table,-

Craig: It’s weird.

John: -chaos.

Craig: Chaos.

John: Why? How do we know to do it in the right order?

Craig: Don’t know. Listening and hearing and reading. It does sound like the sort of thing that I would imagine having to correct for clarity on a paper that, say, a nine-year-old is writing.

John: No, weirdly, you don’t. The nine-year-old will get it right, but a very well-educated speaker who’s not native to English will still struggle with it. It’s inherent rules that we learn, but without learning them.

Craig: For instance, the little old lady who swallowed a fly. There was an old lady. She wasn’t little old. The little old lady who lived in the shoe. There we go. We all hear that. Nobody will ever go, “The old little anything,” because, little old, we just know it. Little old. I wonder if that’s part of it.

John: It’s part of it. Linguists have studied this extensively. The order is opinion, size, age, shape, origin, material or purpose. You could say, “The lovely, tiny, new, square, blue, Italian, silk, racing sled.” Makes sense, but if you try to do this in any other order, it’s chaos.

Craig: Chaos.

John: It’s subjective, objective, inherent is the basic order, but there’s subcategories within it. I just love to say that there are things about English we just don’t know. Other languages, of course, do this. Romance languages, of course, have orders, and they put some things in front of–

Craig: Front, some after.

John: Behind.

Craig: Very annoying.

John: Yes, but we always think like, “Oh, English is just natural,” and it’s just not natural at all. It’s just choices you’ve made.

Craig: If your problem as a non-native English speaker is that you’re putting some of these adjectives in the “wrong place”, you’re still fine.

John: You’re still fine. We still understand it, but we know that it’s a reveal that this is not your native language.

Craig: You will start to do this natural neurological thing called chunking, where instead of one word, there is a cluster of three words that are now one word. Little old is one word for you, really.

John: Yes, totally.

Craig: Little old. Little Red Riding Hood. Little red; just always in that progression. Little red Corvette, always. If you had said, red little Corvette, that would have been very, very weird.

John: Yes, we would have known that he’s not a native speaker. If we had heard that in a song, we’d be like, “Oh, this is some sort of Euro thing.” That’s actually some of the joy of it is it went far.

Craig: It’s on the Euro thing. Also, little red Corvette follows the vowel rule, too.

John: Yes. It’s natural that it goes back, too.

Craig: Yes.

John: Things we learn.

Craig: More evidence that we’re in a simulation.

John: Craig, do you have a One Cool Thing for us?

Craig: I don’t, sorry.

John: [chuckles]

Craig: Yes, I do.

John: Yay.

Craig: Have you seen the little panda Gungun?

John: No. Tell me about little panda Gungun.

Craig: Have you seen Gungun? Oh my God.

John: Is it a cute panda?

Craig: It’s not just a cute panda. It’s not an infant panda. It seems like it’s maybe, I don’t know, eight months old or something. It’s adorable. It is being raised by these zookeepers in China. He is their child, and he acts like a child. He does things like a child, [chuckling] including going, “Meh,” when he wants something. They have three vegetables. She gives him one. He starts to eat it, and she starts to eat it, the other one, the second one. He’s looking at her while she’s eating it like, “What?” Then she picks up the third one; he goes, “Meh.”
[laughter]

Craig: It’s amazing. Sometimes he cries when he’s scared, and then he runs over to the one that he– Gungun is so hysterical. I have to tell you that I know that pandas have pretty privilege. They have the most extraordinary pretty privilege.

John: I was going to say, I suspect you are annoyed that we worry so much about pandas because they can’t reproduce themselves. They’re useless.

Craig: We need them.

John: [laughs]

Craig: They are so adorable. If somebody were like, “Oh my God, look, this little cockroach,” he goes, “Meh,” I’d be like, “Kill it.”
[laughter]

Craig: “Just kill it.” This panda, oh my God, wonderful. Gungun.

John: Gungun.

Craig: Gungun. Sometimes he stands upright and puts his little paws on his hips like a fussy little man. Oh my God. Gungun.

John: Gungun.

Craig: I double-checked. It’s not AI.

John: [chuckles] Yes.

Craig: It is, in fact– [crosstalk]

John: I’m sure there’s probably a lot of knockoff Gungun AI. You can-

Craig: There may be some knockoff Gungun.

John: -find the real ones.

Craig: Yes.

John: Yes, authentic Gungun.

Craig: There is real Gungun to be found.

John: Fantastic.

Craig: Gungun. I also like saying Gungun.

John: That is the main episode this week, but of course, stick around for the bonus segment. Scriptnotes is produced by Meredith Stedman,-

Craig: Gungun.

John: -with help from Lauren Loesberg,-

Craig: Gungun.

John: -edited by Matthew Chilelli.

Craig: Gun.

John: Outro this week is by Gloom Canyon, which doesn’t sound very Gun Canyon.

Craig: Oh, I like that.

John: Come again.

Craig: You still have a house up there.

John: If you have an outro, you can send us a link to ask@johnaugust.com. That’s also the place where you can send questions like the ones we answer often on the show. You’ll find transcripts at johnaugust.com. The Scriptnotes book, of course, is available wherever you buy books. Scriptnotes merch is available at Cotton Bureau. Get both of those for your Austin Film Festival visit.
If you’d like to see us, not just listen to us, follow us on YouTube and Instagram. If you’d like to read us, please subscribe to our weekly newsletter called Interesting, which has lots of links to things about writing. Most of all, thank you to our premium subscribers. You can sign up to become one at scriptnotes.net, where you get all the back-up episodes and bonus segments, like the one we’re about to record on You Can See Everything, and you’ll get all of the spoilers and conversations. Craig, thanks for a fun show.

Craig: Good chat.

[music]

Bonus Segment

↑ Back to Top
John: All right. We’ve never had this many people around the table to talk about anything.

Craig: Ever.

John: Let’s make sure we can identify voices. First, let’s ask you your thumbs up, thumbs down. Meredith Stedman, thumbs up, thumbs down. Thumbs up. Lauren Loesberg, thumbs up, thumbs down.

Lauren Loesberg: Thumbs up.

John: Drew Marquardt, thumbs up, thumbs down.

Drew Marquardt: Thumbs up.

John: Craig Mazin, thumbs up, thumbs down.

Craig: Hated it. No, thumbs up.

John: John August, also thumbs up. We all liked the movie.

Craig: Yes.

John: I have not seen a movie like this in many ways.

Craig: Neither have I. I don’t think anyone has.

John: I’ve never seen a movie that’s told almost entirely in close-ups. I’ve never been in close-ups for so long and not been at all bored.

Craig: Thought a lot about that, by the way, when I was watching it. I’m curious what lenses they were using because the cameras were far enough away. There’s one giveaway shot where we’re looking at the two of them on a couch together. We’re behind the couch, but we know we also get the coverage that is our clean singles from both directions. The cameras are far enough back that we don’t see them in the master shot behind the couch. I think that they’re just using long lenses-

John: On tripods.

Craig: -on tripods, and then I think they’re blowing the shots up. You can blow a shot up in digital a good 20%.

John: The movie would be so different if both Billy and Liz Holmes did not have blue eyes that light could just pass right through. I’ve never seen eyes like that before.

Craig: Different.

John: Yes, it’s different.

Craig: She’s got these headlights that are trying to fix you in place and mesmerize you. He has eyes. They’re telling you, “I want to kill you. I will kill you. I’m about to kill you.” He’s a terrifying guy.

John: Let’s talk about the choice behind putting these three people in a movie together. Because a generous non-confrontational thing you could say is that these are three people with unusual affects. If you’ve met any one of these people individually, you’re like, “Wow, that’s an unusual person.” To have the three of them in this triangle of the movie is so fascinating. Who wants to lead with– Let’s start with Elizabeth Holmes. Drew, is Elizabeth Holmes autistic? Is she acting? What is she doing?

Drew: I came away thinking she was absolutely autistic. I felt like the Who’s on First scene was the one that gave it away to me because I felt like I was watching her– You’re watching any human being not understand something. It felt like she was genuinely confused about what that was about. Nathan Fielder is so good at undressing people with a camera and getting someone like Billy, like anyone, to get behind the mask and the thing that they give for cameras. With her, he doesn’t. I think my conclusion by the end was because there’s nothing to unmask.

Craig: Oh, Drew.

John: Talk to us.

Craig: No, she’s lying, dude.

Drew: No, not at all.

Craig: Yes, she is. She’s lying. She’s lying the way she’s always lied. She’s a liar. She got up in front of rooms full of incredibly powerful people and charmed them and convinced them to– She didn’t do that because she’s autistic. She absolutely understands Who’s on First. She’s lying. She’s lying the entire time.

Drew: Then she is the greatest liar of all time because she never drops it.

Craig: Yes, correct.

Drew: I can’t believe that. I don’t know. It’s either that or she is so traumatized by Theranos falling apart-

Craig: No.

Drew: – that she’s just a husk, that she’s given up all the ability to make any decisions and she’s given that away-

Craig: No

Drew: -and she’s going to– No?

Craig: No, she’s Gungan. Here’s the thing. She’s pretty. She’s got those big eyes. She fixes you in place. She does the things physically that people do when they’re telling the truth. She’s a master of it. She’s a master of keeping her eyes open and keeping her eyes fixed on you and not changing her expression. She is absolutely lying the entire time, the entire time about all of it. Of course, she is.

Drew: I think you’re bringing in bias.

Craig: The bias that she’s a convicted criminal who lied to people?

Drew: She absolutely did. I’m not saying she didn’t do that. I’m not saying Sunny manipulated her into doing the Theranos thing at all.

Craig: Oh no, the other way around.

Drew: I think she comes at it seemingly with the zeal that I don’t think you can get to if you are in any way neurotypical.

Craig: Who says she’s neurotypical?

Lauren: [chuckles]

John: All right. Lauren, Elizabeth Holmes, what is the reality behind that?

Lauren: Coming out of the movie, I felt for her. I felt like Nathan was feeling for her and maybe getting drawn in a little bit and needed Amanda to be like, “Step back, you’re too close.” I was on Drew’s side coming out of the movie, but since spending the week on the internet and seeing all the internet discourse, I’m now maybe more on Craig’s side. I’ve seen a lot of people try to unpack the master manipulation of it, and now I’m like, oh, I think she drew me in the movie.

Craig: She has a fake voice. Dude, even her voice is a lie.

Drew: Yes, but isn’t that masking part of being neurodivergent?

Craig: Not to that extent.

John: Meredith?

Meredith Stedman: I think I sit in between here where when I was watching the movie, of course, there’s the egg scene and the beating of the eggs. That, I think, was hard for any woman to watch, like, “Just let her beat the eggs. What are you doing?” I think that triggered me, that feeling of being like, “She’s a puppet. She’s a puppet.” I did feel bad, and I found myself feeling bad for Liz, by the way. Isn’t her name Liz now?

John: Liz or Lizzy, yes.

Craig: Whatever she wants.

Meredith: I think after a few days, I was like, “Yes.” I think I feel, after it’s settled– I don’t know. I do think she’s probably neurodivergent, but I don’t think that means she isn’t willfully a participant of the dynamic that she’s in and using the dynamic and actually glad to have someone like Billy, who is a lightning rod for criticism around her.

Lauren: Exactly. My experience watching the movie the entire time was like, why is she with this guy? Again, seeing the internet discourse afterward, a lot of people were like, she purposely surrounds herself with people who can take the heat off of her, and that’s why she’s with him. I guess that would make sense.

Craig: He does the dirty work, right? He gets her face out there. He takes some weirdo’s money and puts it out there. She walks away, and he negotiates a financial cut of the documentary that she does not deny knowing about. Also, she had to sign the contract. This was a woman who was the CEO of a corporation. She signs a contract for a deal to make a documentary of her life while she’s in legal trouble and doesn’t read it. “I don’t read contracts.”
No, she’s a liar of the highest level. She lies so committedly that anybody would start to think, “Nobody would take the bit this far,” but she’s like the Andy Kaufman of lying. That’s the thing. She won’t break, ever. She’s still saying that machine works. It does not.

John: Let me venture through my opinion. Like everyone, as you’re watching the movie, you feel like, “Oh–” Especially the Who’s on First– it’s like, “This is a woman who is neurotypical in a way that is like, “Okay, clear.” We’re watching this in close-up, and I feel like everyone else, I feel like, I don’t think she’s acting here. I think she genuinely doesn’t understand stuff, but there’s also an aspect of however her mind works and is doing this thing, she is able to process things in a way that she’s not letting herself process it.
She’s actually, she’s doing a thing. It’s a question of how much does she really understand that she’s doing what she’s doing? She’s guilty of the things she’s guilty of, and she’s aware of it to some degree because she’s not an idiot. I think there’s something that’s not getting through.

Craig: I want to give you an alternative reading on Who’s on First-

John: Please.

Craig: -because here’s what I got out of it. They have an argument prior to that. The argument is about the phrase that this thing can run this many tests. It could not run those tests. She says, “Actually, it’s not a lie. It can run those tests. It has the capability of one day being able to run those tests were it possible to run those tests,” which is an insanely tortured, legalistic, nonsense way that flim-flammers and con artists use language. It’s not like they ever make a mistake that’s not in their favor. It’s always in their favor, like saying, “This thing can do this.”
Nathan says, “But don’t you see how that’s not how a normal person would take it?” I think she sat there and went, “There’s an interesting defense. I’m not a normal person.” Then later he comes to her with this, and she goes, “Oh, I know what this is. I’m good. No, I don’t understand Who’s on First. I guess I don’t see the world the way other people do.” Then her husband chimes in, “See, she doesn’t think the way other people do.” Yes, she does. That was just a lie.

Lauren: I wonder, can it be both that she’s lying and that she also is not understanding how normal people behave?

John: I have experienced people in my real life who are neurotypical to the degree where it’s frustrating to interact with them because they literally can’t understand things that seem very obvious to me. This would be an extreme example of that, but also, to me, what’s not completely implausible.
We won’t solve Elizabeth Holmes here, but let’s talk about Billy, which is, of course, what we really want to talk about. This person is just remarkable. He’s the biggest villain I imagine we’ll see on screens in a decade, and he seems perfectly pitched for this moment. It’s also fascinating to watch a person who just, in the course of two years, physically changes so much.

Craig: That would be the cocaine, I suspect.

Meredith: I was wondering.

Craig: He was sniffing a lot.

John: He was sniffing a lot, but also it was the choice of the filmmakers to include a lot of the sniffing sounds. He was clearly manic at that moment.

Craig: That would be the cocaine, I think.

John: We don’t know that it’s cocaine.

Craig: No, we don’t, I think.

John: He also seems like a pretty good dad. The interactions we see with his kids, that’s better than a lot of dads I see.

Craig: He interacts with them at all, which is better than a lot of dads.

Lauren: How much of it is posturing, though, of making sure, “Oh, the kids are running around any time that Nathan is here and the cameras are here, so we look like we’re really involved?”

Craig: Who knows?

John: Who knows? The truth is we do not know what we’re not seeing that was filmed or not filmed.

Craig: He seems simpler. He’s a jerk, and he’s a controlling jerk, and he’s an egomaniac. He has latched on to somebody that he sees as famous. She’s a famous disaster by the time he meets her, but she is famous. She suckers him in just as he suckers her in. I think it’s mostly she suckers him in. She sees somebody that she can usefully attach to, look normal with, have children with. I think having children, honestly, was part of her deal to try and avoid prison. Also somebody that will do the dirty work and maintain this mafia omerta between them.

Drew: There’s two riddles to Billy to me. One of them is, why is he with her? Because fame, sure, but you are attaching yourself to a sinking ship that you know it, and doubling down and being this protective force. I don’t understand what he’s getting out of it.

Craig: He got a documentary out of it. He got famous out of it. Why would they do this documentary? Why would they do it?

John: Narcissism.

Craig: Yes.

John: That’s why he’s naked in the shower.

Craig: Yes. What he got out of it is the same thing everybody that goes on a reality show gets out of it. He’s famous. We all know his name now. We’ve all seen his dick, which was weird. Why? I guess the why of that was, I guess this guy is okay with showing his dick.

Meredith: My question was, do you think in that moment they were like, “Can we film you in the shower?” How do you think that happened? I was really curious.

Craig: Probably. He was like, “Yes.”

John: Because they’re going for complete transparency. Complete transparency–

Craig: Didn’t include her in the shower.

John: No.

Meredith: Who asked? Did Nathan say, “Can we do this?” Do you think he was like– Do you think it was that? Do you think Nathan broached it, or no one said anything and it just happened?

Drew: I can imagine he’s like, “I’m going to take a shower now.” It’s like, “Great. Can we keep talking?” “Yes.”

Meredith: Got you.

Drew: That’s probably the easy way to get into that segment. The second thing for me with Billy is there’s the moment when Nathan’s interviewing the guy talking about lasers. The laser guy starts saying, “Oh, no, I think she lied.” That is this natural part of this founder mentality is you have to believe your own bullshit. It’s the most compelling argument for her defense, I guess, is maybe in the movie, in a way.

Craig: You took that as a defense.

Drew: There’s that thing, until you make it, that all founders are bullshitters. It’s the most grounded in a way. It’s not like some, “Oh, what are they doing in their brain?” It’s like, yes, she was bullshitting, but she tried and failed. Billy stops that once, the one that he kills.

Craig: Why do you think he did that?

Drew: There’s a lie that he’s protecting of she has never told a lie in her entire life. Why? Why is that paramount to everything else?

Craig: He knows that she has told lies. I think they are in a codependent ego bond. These are two egomaniacs who have bonded into one mafia. They will protect each other to the death while they promote each other’s nonsense because, under it, they do believe they’re building monuments to love, which no one says ever. They both said it independently of each other, which means that they sat there one day and went, “What is it that we’re doing?” “I think we’re building monuments toward love.”

John: Do Elizabeth Holmes’s parents know the truth?

Lauren: I think they see her as a victim.

John: They see her as a victim, not as a villain.

Craig: I think mom does not see her as a victim. I think mom sat there on her phone, not made eye contact. Her daughter was going to prison, and mom didn’t even look up. I think mom is disgusted. That’s my personal opinion. I think dad– Oh, my God, I have never had a more physical reaction in a movie theater than when he casually went, “I’ll tell you. Of course, I know where it all started. It was after she was raped,” and I went, “Ooh.” My hands flew around. Then he just blew on to the next thing.
He also seemed visibly frightened of Billy. Of course, he worked at Enron, incredible. I think the dad, apparently, all men, all of them, is mostly convinced by her. I think the women know. I think mom knows exactly what this kid’s done.

John: Name redacted, but I think you were saying that there’s a famous person in Hollywood who entered her orbit. I had one conversation and was just completely overwhelmed by her and embarrassed by how much he fell under her thrall.

Drew: He went home and told his wife, “You will never understand me on the level that she does because we are both founders.”

Craig: Do you see what I’m saying? That is not some magical side effect of autism. If anything, people who are neurodiverse struggle to make that kind of connection, in part because they don’t have a good sense of what’s going on in the other person’s mind. She has an excellent sense of what’s going on in the other person’s mind.

John: It also reminds me of cult leaders. In that sense, too, which is they just have this certain kind of quality where it’s like, “Oh, my God, I’m completely under your thrall.”

Drew: Love bombing, too. She does that a lot.

Craig: Which is very purposeful. Very purposeful. This is a dangerous person. I’m glad she went to prison. I think that she’s going to come back and try to convince everybody, based on this movie now, that she’s really not. She will throw Billy Evans under the bus, inevitably, just like she threw Sunny under the bus inevitably, inevitably.

John: Let’s talk about Amanda Seyfried and her involvement and the fact that there are actors acting in the movie, which makes it especially complicated. Amanda Seyfried comes in as the voice of truth, a voice of reason. She’s puncturing the balloon a little bit there. She’s able to become Elizabeth Holmes in a sequence that Nathan couldn’t film. It also got uncomfortable because Nathan’s a good actor. He’s not playing his normal, usual character. You don’t know whether he’s more himself or just a different character than we usually see on screen. She’s really good.
It also reminded me a bit of, I really liked Ben McKenzie’s documentary People Are Lying to You for Money, which I thought was great about the crypto industry. He’s incredibly charming in it. There’s moments where him and his wife, Morena Baccarin, are talking, and they’re great. Then we’re realizing, you’re both actors. Is this moment actually really happening, or are you just acting in this moment? I couldn’t quite decide whether, in the movie, you can see everything. Whether the stuff between Nathan and Amanda is legit when they’re playing themselves or not.

Craig: It felt not legit to me. It did feel like it had a slight veneer of performance.

John: Let’s do another take of this.

Craig: Yes, it did. That didn’t detract anything for me at all. Amanda did a great job. The great value, and again, this may have been scripted, and so therefore it may be part of it, and I feel like it probably was, is for her to imply at the very end that Nathan Fielder is in love with Elizabeth Holmes, which he probably did feel at some point, like the unnamed felt. You know the old deal. If you stare directly into somebody’s eyes without blinking for a minute, they will start to fall in love with you.

Meredith: I actually don’t think he– I think he fabricated that. I think Nathan’s really good at that. I think Nathan saw through Billy immediately and was like, “I’m not interested in you.” I think that made for great comedy throughout. I think it was that thing where he’s like, “I don’t want to be manipulated by her.” I think he was obsessed with her. I think he totally led us on in the, “Oh, Nathan Fielder’s catching feelings.”
I think that was so fun because halfway through, I was like, “Oh, I love the loose thread that I’m supposed to think that Nathan’s in love with Elizabeth Holmes.” I do think he was like, I’ve met my match because he’s a master manipulator. I think he was like, “Ooh, which one of us is going to win at this chess game?” I think he was playing the normal Nathan Fielder character, and she was playing her Elizabeth Holmes character.

Craig: It was a good-written ending for it.

Meredith: Yes.

Meredith: Yes. I think they’re a great co-star duo.

Craig: They really are.

Lauren: In the way that we will never know the true Elizabeth Holmes, we will also never know the true Nathan Fielder.

Meredith: Yes.

John: Yes.

Meredith: They’re a power couple of manipulation. Oh my God, if they took over the world, it would be amazing.

Craig: I agree.

John: What I find so fascinating is people who are going into this movie having no idea who Nathan Fielder is because my daughter Amy saw it and doesn’t really know who Nathan Fielder was. She’s like, “I found him so creepy for the first half of the movie until it wins him over.” The movie doesn’t have– It’s not told from Nathan Fielder’s point of view. We don’t have the VoiceOver that we usually get in Nathan Fielder projects. It was like, he’s just this guy you’re seeing filming.

Craig: He stands there.

John: He stands there.

Craig: It is such a great choice to have him stand there. He stands there with this slouchy posture and dead look in his eyes, like a predator, like the predator on a playground, just like, [makes sound] and too close, but not too far. It’s in the middle kind of, a weird spot to stand. He’s always there. He portrays himself as a problem, but, man, there are some great moments in this thing.

Lauren: Did everyone have the experience watching it in the theater in the beginning where people would just laugh anytime he came on the screen because they’re used to other Nathan Fielder stuff? Him being in a room with the two of them was just inherently funny.

John: Exactly.

Craig: It was. People definitely laughed when he would do his uncomfortable things like, “Why did you take the eggs?” Which made me laugh because once he took the eggs, I went, “Why did he take the eggs?” I stopped paying attention, and I just started thinking about the eggs. Then he said it like–

John: Yes, absolutely.

Craig: Oh my God, thank God, I wasn’t the only one.

John: A voice of reason.

Craig: Yes, voice of reason. Also, when Billy Evans goes, “I know exactly how you’re feeling.” No, you don’t.
[chuckling]

Lauren: Line of the year. My absolute favorite shot was when Billy comes out of the shower, and Nathan is in the hallway holding the monitor and Billy scoots by him in a towel.

John: I felt like the movie was trying to figure out how much it wanted to be a Nathan Fielder comedy project and not. There’s a moment where he goes out and listens to rock music in his car.
It felt like it was out of a different thing. Then there’s moments later on in the movie where he’s waiting for the call, and he’s in the hotel room. I felt like that wasn’t a funny Nathan Fielder. That was actually a frustrated, angry Nathan Fielder if that’s really what happened, because that could all be performance and that may just have been an act in the moment.

Craig: Exactly. Of course, there’s the strange moral complication that the crime that we uncover as the movie goes on is that Billy Evans has quietly negotiated profit from this documentary, which is not orthodox, and hasn’t told her.

John: We’re feeling like we’re complicit for having bought a ticket to this movie that we’re watching.

Craig: Even though it becomes clear to me that she absolutely knew, they both give the money back. Do you know who does profit off the movie? Nathan Fielder, the entire way. It is an interesting thing to have him go and say, “You really shouldn’t take this money. Then that goes to you.”

John: To argue about documentary ethics with Nathan Fielder, it feels like a real strike.
[chuckling]

Craig: At that point, I think the money should just go to Cedars-Sinai Hospital or something.

John: The ethics of paying a person who’s in a documentary, I can see it because it is their story you’re telling. They’re giving you their time to do the thing. Yes, it’s complicated because these are criminals, but also it destroys it.

Craig: I don’t even think they’re allowed to profit off. Isn’t there that Son of Sam law or something?

Meredith: If you’re in jail, yes, you can’t profit off your own crimes, if you’ve been convicted of the crimes.

Craig: She would not be– Oh, but he could profit off of it.

Meredith: He could profit off of it, which is why–

Craig: That’s why they did it that way.

Meredith: That’s why they did it that way.

Craig: Here’s the thing, I can’t believe she’s still fooling people. It’s incredible. A lot of people are going to be fooled by this. They’re going to be fooled by her. She knows exactly what she’s doing. She got $1 billion of investments. She got money from Henry Kissinger and George Shultz. She convinced Walgreens.

She was firing people. She fired people that went on to commit suicide. She had everybody signing NDAs. She walked around with security all the time, everywhere she went. She outright, straight up lied to the faces of 60 Minutes reporters. She lied from the jump. From the very beginning, she knew that her technology was not possible. Somehow, we still think that she’s a victim? No.

Meredith: I think it’s interesting because I don’t think this is the first time I’ve felt this in watching a documentary or hearing a story where I believe all that’s true. I’m like, “I do think she knows.” I do think she knows deep down the difference between it can do it and it can do it right now, and how that’s legally different. Then I felt myself feeling bad when she really wanted a snack in jail, when she really wants the turkey jerky. I’m like, “Just get a turkey jerky.” Things like that, it’s weird how it can still pull on my human heartstrings.

Craig: She got what she wanted, didn’t she?

Meredith: She did get that turkey jerky.
[chuckling]

Craig: She wasn’t starving. She just wanted to eat some turkey jerky. She got him to use some of the time that he had to interview. Billy’s coming. She showed up late. The time is taking away. She gets him to go over there and buy her a snack. Everything she does. She is a super villain. Billy is a villain. Elizabeth Holmes is a super villain.

Meredith: He is a henchman.

Craig: He is a henchman. He is. He’s a henchman.

John: To get back to Amanda Seyfried really quick, I came out being like, “She’s a hero.” I thought she was incredibly brave in that. I’ve gotten pushback on that.

Craig: Let me ask you, brave how?

John: I think to put herself in the middle of that, in the middle of all that sticky stuff and like–

Craig: But she already has.

John: She has to an extent, but to have her ego so revealed by that, where she gets defensive about the product, where she’s like, “Oh, no, we didn’t lie,” and all that stuff. I know she could have said that. They said that. Then having like, she’s not correct throughout the whole thing. She’s often wrong. It’s a little bit messy, but just to let herself be seen in that way, I think. Then to continue to push and to try and do what she thinks is right, I think.

Also, I think she had safety with Nathan Fielder that no one else did because Nathan Fielder had previously worked with Emma Stone and other Hollywood people. I think she was going to come out of this okay in terms of the treatment of that, but you can’t know popular culture-wise how people are going to respond. It’s Jesse Eisenberg choosing not to go back as Mark Zuckerberg again because he doesn’t want to be forever associated with this. Amanda Seyfried is going to be more associated with Elizabeth Holmes than ever now because of this. Also, I like her so much more.

Craig: I think she’s always been incredibly likable. I’ve never met her, but she’s always seemed to me to be a very intelligent person, which is not intelligent, like intelligent, intelligent and great actor. Those Venn diagrams are not always the same. She seems very intelligent. I think from a very intelligent, very career-minded point of view, this was a no-brainer because it’s an A24 glossy documentary that he showed it to her.
Remember, he showed her everything up to the point she shows up. She sees how good this is. This is a no-brainer to jump on board and be a part of it. She knows what the tone. She knows what it’s going to be like. I found myself thinking about her makeup often. There’s a lot of scenes where there’s no makeup. There’s some scenes where there’s a little makeup.

John: There’s scenes where she’s playing Liz in prison, and she has the terrible chapped lips and all that stuff.

Craig: Yes, they put the chapped lips on. I think she made an excellent choice to be in this and fulfilled her role beautifully. Let me refer us all back to Gungan. Also a hypnotizing woman with hypnotizing eyes, a brilliant choice to portray Elizabeth Holmes. I found myself wanting to believe anything she says almost instantly because I’m a sucker. She’s a great actor and she’s very smart person. No question.

John: Fearless, I felt.

Craig: I don’t know about fearless. That’s where I got to say, to me–

John: Drew is an actor. We have a fearless actor.

Craig: We watched the documentary. It’s like, how fearless are you if you can see two-thirds of a movie and then someone’s like, “I want to put you in this third?” You’re like, “This is a great movie.”

John: To be like, I’m going to go and I want to sit with Billy at dinner and see what I can listen out of him. You already know they’re hostile to you. You already know that they hate your guts and they talk in this scene thinking about you.

Craig: That was interesting because I think that scene, I did think, okay, she feels like she could charm this guy. He was definitely in a mood and definitely angry at her. It turned very quickly into a big argument about– What’s his name? [chuckles]

John: Charlie Kirk.

Craig: Charlie Kirk. At that point, it just gets silly. Then right back on track when two of them and she’s like, “Oh my God, he is batshit nuts.” That was fun to have this person fly in from outside to be us. She did a great job representing us. I can’t get on board with the notion that she’s done something brave here. She did something smart.

Lauren: I think being in her house with the children of a woman who is in prison, who you know hates you–

Meredith: When she said, “You’re wonderful.”
[chuckling]

Lauren: Yes, and then-

Craig: That was crazy.

Lauren: -Elizabeth calls from jail. You are in her house. You have played her. You have been her. You are actively still playing her, which she doesn’t know. That’s a crazy situation. You can’t say that isn’t a brave thing to do.

Craig: I can.
[chuckling]

Craig: I can. You’ve got cameras. It’s constructed, and it’s editable. I can say that.

Meredith: To your point of though, she thought she could charm him, Amanda. I think that she did. I think we didn’t see the beginning of that dinner or whatever it was. I think that scene made me realize, oh, this is how shallow these people are. They’re like, “We don’t like her. Oh, she’s coming. Great.”

Craig: That, honestly, that’s everybody with famous people.

Meredith: Yes, it is.

Craig: Everybody.

Meredith: That’s how he was to Elizabeth and why they’re together. It was the same thing. “Oh, I don’t know who she is.” You just love famous people.

Craig: Yes, it is very strange. People will say horrible things about famous people online all day long. If they met any of those people, they’d pee their pants and get an autograph. It’s just how it is.

John: It’s almost Halloween. Let’s think about, are there Halloween costumes we want to do from this movie? I will start, I want to be Amanda Seyfried’s farting horse.

Meredith: Yes, perfect. In Austin?

John: In Austin, absolutely.

Lauren: I would like to be her baby in the bassinet.

John: Yes, the bouncy bassinet. Very good at rocking with the foot. That’s the weird thing. They seem like actually pretty decent parents. They are sociopathic perhaps, but–

Craig: Yes. The easiest for me is Nathan Fielder. Get some sweatpants, get a ratty T-shirt, get a bad pair of Sony headphones, slouch and just stare. Just stare at people.

John: Look down at your little monitor in your hand.

Craig: Look down your little monitor and stare. It’d be great.

Meredith: A lot of couples costume potential. I like doing Nathan Fielder and Elizabeth Holmes in the ocean. I think that would be a nice pairing.

Drew: Sorry, I know we’re doing costumes. The end shot, is that him and her in the ocean?

Lauren: Yes.

Meredith: The shot was earlier, and I didn’t recognize it was them, and then they go closer later.

Drew: Because he talks about the cold water, the fear of cold water.

John: He did do it.

Drew: He does it.

Craig: Yes.

Drew: Okay.

Meredith: Because they’re in love.

Craig: That is the art.

John: Drew, costume.

Drew: Costume. I want to be the dyed hair and sunglasses that Nathan Fielder gives Liz Holmes to run away.

Craig: Oh, the present.

Drew: Yes, the present.

Craig: The awkward joke.

Drew: The awkward joke.

Lauren: I was just going to say, I would like to share a fun thing from an article. This is an article in Vanity Fair by Dan Adler, You Can’t See Everything. Basically, he talks about he wanted to interview Billy Evans, and it became a whole thing. This quote from the article, “Evans did agree, at least, that I could print a list of his animals. A blue Argentine tegu.” I don’t know what that is.

John: Is that the thing that looks like a iguana? I don’t know.

Lauren: Oh, right.

John: Yes, that was an iguana.

Meredith: It is the thing on the table. It’s the little lizard. A big lizard, rather.

Lauren: A corn snake, a curly-haired tarantula, blue death-feigning beetles, and two Burmese forest tortoises.

John: Come on. That pushes me to sociopaths. That’s weird. In a house where they have two young children.

Craig: Cocaine’s a hell of a drug.
[chuckling]

Craig: Cocaine’s a hell of a drug, yes.

Lauren: Also, what happened to her husky?

John: She talked about the husky. We don’t see that husky. They have a giant dog in San Diego, but we don’t see that dog at all in Austin. Maybe it’s out of shot.

Craig: Maybe the dog died.

John: The dog could die.

Lauren: Yes, but I’m also worried about the timeline of the husky because she said she had the scratch on her face when he was a puppy when they met.

John: Oh, yes. That’s right. It would have been young.

Lauren: Interesting that they had a husky, the blue eyes of the husky. Oh, wow.

Craig: “Why would I deceive you? I have no reason to deceive you.” You have a million reasons.

Lauren: Are you deceiving me right now?

Craig: Why would I? I have no reason to be. Good chat.

John: Good chat.
[chuckling]

Lauren: Good chat.

[music]

Related Posts

  1. Places, Everyone
  2. Your First Produced Film
  3. Craig Takes Questions

Primary Sidebar

Each week, screenwriters John August and Craig Mazin discuss screenwriting and things that are interesting to screenwriters, everything from the craft to the business to the best ways to get yourself writing.

The most recent 20 episodes are available for free on this site and Apple Podcasts. The entire 750+ episode back catalog, plus bonus content and episodes, are available to Premium Subscribers.

Where to Find It

  • Apple Podcasts
  • Spotify
  • RSS

Scriptnotes Premium

  •   Bonus segments and episodes
  •   Early access to events
  •   750+ episode back catalog
  •   Use your favorite podcast player.

Join now

Scriptnotes Shirts

Every Scriptnotes shirt is available on-demand from Cotton Bureau. 14 designs and counting.

These high-quality tees are super soft and available in all sizes, including children’s and hoodies.

Browse the catalog

© 2026 John August — All Rights Reserved.