What changes when you take off your writer hat and put on your director hat? In this compendium episode, John, Craig, and Scriptnotes coordinator Lauren Loesberg review directing advice previously given on the podcast.
John and Craig offer Lauren pointers on directing her next project. They also answer a listener question about directing actors “on the page.”
In our bonus segment for premium subscribers, we discuss film festivals. Why would writers go? And what can you expect to get out of the experience?
Links:
- Three Page Challenge
- Fruit Fly by Josh Silver
- Mailbox Toluca Lake
- Forgotten Realms: Heroes of Faerûn
Download the episode here!
Get your copy of The Scriptnotes Book and become a Scriptnotes Premium member today! For more content on the craft of writing check out Inneresting our weekly-ish newsletter about screenwriting and things that are interesting to screenwriters.
Scriptnotes is produced by Meredith Stedman and edited by Matthew Chilelli. Our coordinator is Lauren Loesberg.
Outro by Nick Moore (send us yours!)
Email us at ask@johnaugust.com
Full Episode Transcript:
- Prologue
- Lauren’s Short Film and Past Advice
- Flashback: Advice for First-Time Directors
- Flashback: Advice for a First Feature
- Flashback: Eva Victor on Directing
- Script Directions and a Listener Question
- One Cool Thing
- Bonus Segment
Prologue
John August: Hello and welcome. My name is John August.
Craig Mazin: My name is Craig Mazin.
John: This is Scriptnotes. It’s a podcast about screenwriting and things that are interesting to screenwriters. Today on the show, what changes when you take off your writer hat and put on your director hat? Craig, what is a good director hat?
Craig: It’s going to be sweaty-
John: Sweaty, yes.
Craig: -full of anxiety.
John: I think a beret can be nice, but a ball cap is classic.
Craig: I’m a ball cap guy.
John: I’m a ball cap guy, too.
Craig: Keeps the sun off my bald head.
John: You, me, Ron Howard, ball caps.
Craig: Ball caps. Ball or bald? Both.
[laughter]
John: That’ll be the starter advice about directing, but we’ll go even further because we’re going to offer advice to our newest Scriptnotes team member as she prepares to shoot her short film, and in the process, look back at her directing advice over the past 15 years of this program.
Craig: That ought to be interesting.
John: In our bonus segment for premium members, let’s answer a listener question about how writers should think about film festivals.
Craig: Oh, well, I’ve never been to one, John, so this ought to be interesting.
John: We often go to the Austin AFF-
Craig: True.
John: -which is really a more screenwriters conference. We’re going back again this year.
Craig: We are.
John: That’s new. We are going back. It’s the end of October. We’ll do a live Scriptnotes. We’ll do a live three-page challenge.
Craig: Great.
John: We’re going to see if we can also find a time to sign a bunch of Scriptnotes books while we’re there, so we can find a good venue for signing some books because last time we were there, we were hyping the book, but it hadn’t come out yet.
Craig: It hadn’t come out yet. The world’s lightest book had not yet arrived.
John: Now it’s out there in the world.
Craig: Now it is out there. That book, it’s like someone cast Feather Fall on a book.
John: It’s true. It’s great. I love it for the book, and it’s turned out great.
Craig: A lot of question marks on our listeners. What’s Feather Fall? They ask. If you don’t know, you don’t know.
John: Summary, Austin, we’re going to do a live show probably Friday night. Saturday morning, it’s going to be a three-page challenge. If you’re going to be at Austin and would like to join us at the three-page challenge and have us possibly look at your three pages, that would be fantastic. We’d love to bring you up on stage to talk about the three pages you gave us. If you want to be considered for the three-page challenge, go to johnaugust.com/threepage, all spelled out. It’s the standard form, but there’s an extra special checkbox that says, “Yes, I will be at the Austin Film Festival.”
We’ll only be picking from that pool for people who are going to be possibly joining us on stage at the three-page challenge. In addition to the Austin Film Festival, we’re also talking about doing Sundance. Sundance has moved back to Boulder, Colorado.
Craig: We were?
John: You and I had texted about this.
Craig: Did we?
John: We did, but you don’t remember because you’ve been–
Craig: You had me in a low moment there, John, clearly. I was like, “Okay, I’ll do whatever you say.” We’re going to Sundance?
John: Sundance has invited us to do a panel there, to do a live show at-
Craig: Great.
John: -Sundance Film Festival in Boulder, Colorado.
Craig: Your hometown.
John: My hometown.
Craig: Oh my God, you’re the king of Boulder.
John: I’m not the king of Boulder.
Craig: Will there be a parade when you arrive? There ought to be.
John: There should be a parade.
Craig: There should be a parade.
John: I’m going to be there at the Sundance Film Festival. We’re going to try to do a live show. No details yet, but just keep it on your list.
Craig: When does that occur?
John: In January now.
Craig: Okay, that sounds great.
John: Yes, great.
Craig: Great.
John: Let’s do some follow-up because since we last recorded, a few things have happened, a few things have changed. I have been practicing a new activity. I want you to guess what it is. I’m going to give you three choices. The first is it juggling, is it harmonica, or is it indoor climbing? What have I been doing a lot of since you last saw me, Craig?
Craig: I want to rule out indoor climbing because it’s not like the other two. It feels like you would have been sneakier. I don’t know how much practice you need to do with a harmonica. It’s always in tune, but obviously there is skill involved to playing it correctly. I want to say juggling.
John: You are correct, juggling.
Craig: Juggling.
John: You know me well.
Craig: I can juggle.
John: You can juggle?
Craig: Yes.
John: Great.
Craig: I can juggle three, and I can juggle two.
John: Juggling two is barely juggling.
Craig: Here’s what I can do. I haven’t done it in a while, but I feel like I can juggle three, turn it into two, and then go back to three.
John: That’s good. You’re ahead of me right now.
Craig: That’s a thing.
John: I’ve actually been just doing the fundamentals of juggling. Just a little bit every day, so I’m now up to a place where I can keep three balls in the air for five passes. That’s as much as I can do-
Craig: That’s great.
John: -but I’m going to get better.
Craig: It is a lovely thing. I did this when I was in college; I got a book, and I followed the instructions. It’s a funny thing. Once you learn how to do it, you’re like, “How do we all not know how to do this?” What it is is complete faith. It’s like falling backwards. You’re falling upwards all the time. You’re just throwing things in the air all the time, just imagining that they’ll be back, and then they are.
John: It’s also proprioception. It’s knowing where things are in space and where your hands are in space. I’m generally terrible at choreography. I have a hard time learning choreography. This is what it is. It’s learning the movements.
Craig: When I see a chorus line, they’re like, three, four. I’m like, “How does three, four help anyone? You just said two numbers. Three, four.”
John: The ability to watch someone do a thing once and then replicate it, remarkable.
Craig: Amazing. The memory that performers have in general, actors have this incredible memory for lines. I give them just scads of dialogue to do every day. They learn it every day without fail. Then choreography and musicians, just the memory involved, it’s insane.
John: It’s great. I always respect when people can just do a thing that I can’t do well.
Craig: Good for you. I’m glad that you’re juggling.
John: Yes, it’s fun.
Craig: Seems like the kind of thing you would do, like Halloween, to see you outside just juggling three pumpkin-shaped balls like, “Hey, happy Halloween, folks.” I can see that.
John: Not only did you miss out on my juggling-
Craig: Damn.
John: -you missed out on three guests. We had three great guests.
Craig: I’ve never heard of any of them.
John: We started with Erin Gibson, who was talking about assembling a career. You may have a general plan for how your career’s going to go, but things happen. Being the smart, funny person is an applicable skill, no matter what the projects are. She put together a career that way. Zoe Kazan was just on.
Craig: Great, Zoe Kazan. I’m so sorry I missed her. I know her parents very well. It was almost like I wanted to be here to talk to my godniece or something. I was sad I missed her.
John: She’s very smart. We talked to her about her adaptation of East of Eden, and of course, Aaron Sorkin.
Craig: Never heard of him.
John: Never heard of him.
Craig: Who? I’m glad. I would have been scared. I told you this. I would have been legitimately sweaty and nervous to talk to him. You were calm.
John: I was calm. The truth is, it’s sometimes challenging for you and I both to interview a person because you want the person doing most of the talking rather than us doing most of the talking. It worked out well, and he was delightful. I’m glad to have you back, Craig. That show is mostly you and me, so it’s nice to have you back here.
Craig: You and me, but mostly me. We’re going to do the show forever. If I sing anymore, we have to pay money.
John: We have to stop. The other thing I’ve been working on for the past couple of months while you’ve been back and forth to Canada is the Creators Coalition on AI, which is a group that’s trying to figure out how to define our terms and set standards for the people actually working in our industry for what are the impacts of AI in our industry, and then help control what’s going to happen and what’s not going to happen.
Craig: Have you guys thought about asking ChatGPT?
John: We’ve never-
Craig: No, because that would be antithetical.
John: What we actually did is we interviewed a bunch of people in all segments of the industry and came up with definitions, but also looked up what are the impacts in those specific industries because, for writers, we have a sense of what that’s like because these things generate text, but what is it like for animal handlers or assistant editors or stunt coordinators, and what are the impacts in those industries? What I can point out, listeners, too, is we now have a comprehensive glossary of definitions of things in the industry that we need to focus on and have a definition for.
I was involved in things like what is a character, what is a story, what is narrative, sort of fundamental building blocks because a lot of the other things were hinging on that. Then SAG-AFTRA had to come in like, what is a likeness, what is a performance, and trying to figure out that stuff so that we can get a sense of a handle on that we’re all talking about the same things. That’s one of the hardest aspects of this is we don’t even know what we’re discussing.
Craig: This is meant to feed into union negotiations?
John: Union negotiations and governmental action policy.
Craig: Oh, well, I’m so sorry to tell you that that’s going to take a while. Probably they’ll come up with something right after the AI apocalypse occurs. That’s what I would imagine. Have you guys talked to– in your discussions, I don’t know if you’ve brought in IA, have you?
John: Oh, all the unions and girls are a part of the discussion.
Craig: IA is the big one. They’ve really got to dig in.
John: Yes, because they also have members who cover such widely different aspects of things.
Craig: Basically everything other than writing, directing, and acting. They cover it all.
John: Of course, visual effects is one of the biggest points of focus because there’s practical effects, there’s digital effects, there’s color timing, there’s everything else that happens. I’ll point everybody to the website, which shows the glossary and shows where we’re at in terms of listing impacts, but there’s also a survey. If you are a person who works in this industry, not as a writer, but as anything else, like hair and makeup or anything else, it’d be great if you could click through and answer five questions about your specific job because we want to make sure that we are really taking a full breath of this.
Also, if you’re not in a guild-covered area, but you work in podcasting or related fields, music production, there’s a lot of stuff there that we are blind about. We want to make sure that this covers everything.
Craig: Weird that we’re blind about podcasting. No one expects me to know anything about it, that’s for sure.
John: We got Meredith and Lauren here to help us out.
Craig: Meredith and Lauren.
Lauren’s Short Film and Past Advice
↑ Back to Top
John: Creators Coalition on AI. I will put a link in the show notes for that. Thank you, everyone, who was fully on the survey. Now our marquee topic is directing. The impetus for this episode came because Lauren Loesberg, our coordinator here, is about to direct her short film as part of the STAR Program at USC.
Craig: Here we go.
John: We have a long history of, our Scriptnotes people making short films. Megan McDonald did, Stuart Friedel did-
Craig: Drew.
John: -Drew and Matthew Chilelli, our editor, made a short film great for instant advice. Both Meredith, and Daniel, who works for us, are also prepping films to shoot. I like that we’re a podcast about making movies that actually makes movies.
Craig: I think that’s fantastic. This is your first time?
Lauren: It is not my first time.
Craig: Oh, thank God.
John: We got that out of the way then.
John: Lauren, tell us about what you’ve done directing so far and what this new project is.
Lauren: I’ve done quite a bit of directing so far. I’m in grad school now. I did my undergrad in film, so I made a bunch of shorts when I was in college. I did an indie feature when I was 24, which is out and people can watch it. Now I’m trying to level up and do bigger things. This new project is a romantic fantasy movie. It’s going to involve a lot more sets and visual effects and things that I haven’t really gotten to do yet.
Craig: Fantastic.
John: She’s been scouting locations, figuring out stuff. She’s been making script tweaks. You’ve also been listening through back episodes for our previous advice on directing. This will be a compendium, but then we’ll also come back in and offer some new thoughts on things. Talk us through what episodes you found and what was useful in those episodes.
Lauren: The first one we’re going to listen to is episode 176, where you give advice to a first-time director of their own script. That first-time director also happens to be Scriptnotes’ own Matthew Chilelli. There’s some really great advice there. Then in episode 687, many years later, you answer essentially the same question from another listener, but give different pieces of advice.
Craig: We just say the opposite of what we said before.
John: Did any of our advice conflict with other things or just different aspects of it?
Lauren: No, not at all. You just said different things, all of which I think are still applicable and helpful. Finally, we revisit episode 721, where you speak with Eva Victor about preparing themselves to direct their debut feature, Sorry, Baby.
Craig: So good.
John: I remember that episode pretty clearly.
Craig: I’m obsessed.
John: Eva was great.
Craig: I’m obsessed. Eva Victor is special. That’s a special one.
John: I see them in an upcoming feature that they’re opposite. I think they’re in, I think, Together Soon.
Craig: That is a great pair. Eva Victor is one of those actors where I’m like, “Okay, you can pair them with anyone. Feels like a good pairing.” It is exciting to me to see when people who are naturally good at acting and also naturally good at writing and directing just start to head down the writing and directing path. I do believe it is rarer. I sound like a chauvinist there. It’s rare. Even when you’re really, really good. There are certain actors where I’m like, “Okay, stop. Just act.” I don’t need Daniel Day-Lewis writing anything. I really don’t. To write and direct something beautifully is so rare. As good of an actor as Sarah Polley is, I get very excited when I know she’s making a movie.
John: Let’s take a listen to these clips from the past, and then we’ll rejoin here in 2026 to talk about next steps.
Flashback: Advice for First-Time Directors
↑ Back to Top
MUSIC – FIRST FLASHBACK SEGMENT:
John: Our first is a question that comes from Matthew Chilelli, who is the person who edits his podcast. He wrote this question, and I said, “You know what? We’ll answer your question on the air. You’ll get to hear it first because you’ll edit the episode that has the answer to your question. Matthew Chilelli and his writing partner are directing a movie that they raised money for on Kickstarter. His question was, what advice would you give to the first-time director of his own script? I’m like, “That’s a great question.” I had some thoughts, and I’m sure Craig will have some thoughts too because we both directed and we both learned a lot.
My quick bullet points of advice is to remember that you’re not there to throw a party. One of my first real worries about directing a movie is I wanted everyone to be happy, and I wanted to make sure that the set was comfortable and that everyone was having a good time. Then I realized, you know what? This isn’t a party. It’s not my job to make sure everyone’s having a good time. It’s my job to make sure that everyone has the information they need so they can do their jobs really, really well. Once I stopped thinking about myself as host and started thinking about myself as the person who’s directing the movie, things got much happier and better, and everyone was happier.
You will be facing 1,000 questions. I was terrified of the 1,000 questions. Should it be a green shirt or a red shirt? Like this, like this? Do you want a wider lens, a tighter lens? Here are some things. You will usually have an answer. Just pick an answer. Answers are great. Although you can also say, “I don’t know.” You can solicit their opinions. You can figure out what the choices really mean. You can also say, “None of the above.” If none of the choices that are presented to you are the correct choices, say, “None of the above,” and let them come back to you with more choices.
While you’re directing, always remember what the intention is of the scene and what the intention is at the moment. When you’re in the middle of directing a scene, and things are going crazy, and you’re turning around, shooting from one side to the other side, and things are just nuts, it’s so easy to forget what the scene is actually about. Making notes to yourself before the day starts, like, “The scene is about this,” is incredibly useful. The minimum viable scene will be about this. Rely on that. If you are directing actors, direct actors I find works best with verbs. It’s very hard for an actor to be happy, be sad, be angrier. Give an actor a verb to play.
You can say, “Don’t let him walk through that door,” or you can give him a simile. “Can we try that same moment, but as if he’s just said the most horrifying thing imaginable to you?” That’s something an actor can do. An actor can’t be an adjective. Those are my quick run-throughs of advice.
Craig: All spectacular suggestions. I agree with every single one of them.
John: Cool.
Craig: I’ll only add the following. When you’re directing a movie that it’s your first time, and you’ve written the script, you will have a natural tendency to want to be the person that is defending the guy that came before you, the screenwriter. In other situations where we’ve written a script and somebody else directs it, we go, “Oh my God, what are you doing to my screenplay?” It’s bad, and you think, “When I get in there, I can defend this.” However, that’s not the person you should be worrying about. When you direct, the person that you should be solely concerned with is the you in the future who is in the editing room. That’s the person you’re taking care of.
That is the person who needs you right now to figure this out. Give that person options. When you’re a first-time director, you may think, “I’ve figured out; I know exactly what I want to do with this.” You may think that’s the name of the game, but sometimes the name of the game is collect options. Then you’re going to find this movie and write this movie in editorial. Matthew is an editor, so he understands this better than most. To that end, I believe in shot listing, particularly for a first-time director, and especially if you’re dealing with limited time, which typically a first-time director is. You don’t have a lot of days where you can go, “We didn’t figure it out today. I’ll figure it out tomorrow.”
It doesn’t go that way for you. You got to get the day’s work done. Shot list. As a writer, we are obviously absorbed with all writerly things: character, dialogue, theme, scenario. As a director, take a moment to just think about aesthetics. Think about your color palette. Think about movies that look the way you want this movie to look. Think about how you want to move the camera. Do you want long lenses, wide lenses? By the way, if you’re not sure what those things are, pick up a book. There’s all sorts of instructional things online now, so you can learn.
Really think about how you want it to look, how you want the camera to move and feel, because that is essentially the directorial equivalent of theme for the screenwriter. Without theme as a screenwriter, we tend to just wander. Without some sort of unifying visual concept as a director, you’re just collecting footage and making a big TV show. Work on all those things, but most importantly, really, really care for your future self who will be in editorial, because that future self is the one who’s going to, every director, first time, 20th time, at some point in editorial, will curse themselves for what they didn’t do. You want to try and limit the amount of cursing of yourself you end up doing.
John: I think that’s fantastic advice. Let’s talk about what shot list is, because I think sometimes people get confused about that term. There’s storyboarding. Storyboarding is when you’re sketching out what you think the shots are going to be like to build a sequence. A shot list is a much more practical thing. It’s literally a thing you’re probably holding in your hand, which is like a bullet-point list like, “These are the shots I need to make this scene.” That’s something you probably would do in pre-production. You’d figure out what the shot list would be for a scene.
Honestly, it’s a thing you might do in the morning before you started that day’s work, and you’re going to hopefully have people you can trust and talk through that shot list with. The people who are so crucial are your first AD and your director of photography. I found it to be so useful to walk through with Nancy Schreiber, my DP, and my line producer. These are the shots I need in this scene. She could tell me, “Let’s prioritize this and prioritize this because of light.” That was so useful. Also, when you’re making your shot list, prioritize within that, because there are going to be some shots you’re just not going to get.
You need to be able to tell the scenes, even if you never got that second close-up that you really wanted, okay. That’s why you put that at the bottom of your list. No matter if you’re making a tiny movie or a giant movie, there’s going to be stuff that you just don’t get. Protecting that future editor itself, you want to make sure you get as much of the stuff you do need, and this extra stuff is just gravy.
Craig: That’s absolutely right. That is a perfect description of a shot list. What you find as a first-time director is that directing, whatever you thought about directing, is wrong, and that a huge amount of what directing is, is breaking moments down geometrically. It is literally figuring out how to capture a moment through angles. The angles could be moving, and they could be different sizes, but ultimately, you’re fracturing a moment into various geometric angles that will be repeated so that you can edit them together.
Understanding the geometry of your scene is really important before you shot list, because sometimes, if you think about it, you’ll say, “I don’t want to break this down. I actually think this is a one-er. I think that’s how this works. I don’t want coverage here. I want this to be about these two people playing something in the moment together.” If it’s a one-er, and you know it’s a one-er, no problem. Everything’s a trade-off. You’ll probably do nine takes of that, but there’s no more coverage, so you’re done with it. If you’re doing traditional coverage of two people talking, you’ve got yourself a master and overs and closes.
You don’t have to do as many takes of each one, but there’s a lot more setups. One thing to do as the first-time director of your own screenplay is to go through your screenplay and start asking yourself this question. How would this moment be best broken down geometrically? What do I want to see and how? It will help you make your shot list. Then, as you said, your DP and your first AD will have all sorts of great ideas to add to it and to make it more efficient.
John: One last thing, thinking about that future person you’re going to be when you’re in the editing room, a lot of times as you’re watching a shot happen before you, you say, “Oh, that was good, but this thing wasn’t good. It was almost right, but this wasn’t quite right. If you know you’re going to be cutting it, then it doesn’t have to be flawless all the way through. It’d be great if it were flawless, where you had that one take that’s fantastic, but pushing for that eighth take to try to get one perfect take through on one person’s coverage is almost never worth it.
If you know you have the moments, if you know I can see and feel what this is like, then you’re wasting a lot of your day to try to get that perfect eighth take when you have the stuff you need in those earlier takes.
Craig: It’s why before you direct anything, you must have experience editing something. You must. You need to know where the scissors come in and where the scissors can’t come in. You need to know when something is married to something else. If one half of it’s no good and one half of it is good, it’s no good. Matthew happily has that experience. That’s a huge part of it. It’s how you figure out how to break a moment down very often.
John: A great segue to our next topic, which is our Perfect series, and this time it’s the Perfect Director. I want to take a look at the Perfect Director from the writer’s point of view, since we’re mostly a writers’ podcast, but also from what a perfect director looks like from an actor’s point of view, from a different department head’s point of view. How does a director do her job the best, and what are the tools and techniques she’s using to make the best movie? Obviously, a very wide topic, but Craig, how should we start?
Craig: Let’s start with what we’re most comfortable with, I suppose, which is what we want. From a screenwriting point of view, when we work with the director, what do we want? I’m going to dispense with the obvious ones. We want them to be good. We want them to know how to shoot. We want them to be visually interesting. We want them to know how to work with great actors. We want them to be really specific, make terrific choices. Of course, what a lot of screenwriters will say is, we want them to shoot the script. I don’t want the director to shoot the script. I want the director to shoot the movie of the script.
Here’s what I want most of all. I want the director to presume respectfully that if something is in the script, it’s there for a reason. I think the biggest mistake directors make vis-à-vis screenwriters is when they read a screenplay, they presume that some of it is just whatever. There’s moments that have to happen, but then there are moments inside of the moments that are like, “You know what, actually, I’d love to do this,” or “I’d love to do that,” or “It’ll be more fun if the camera’s here, more fun if the camera’s there,” or “This just feels like a waste of time.” Not always, depending on the quality of the screenwriter, but I would argue if it’s a good screenwriter, 99% of the time, that is a huge mistake.
It is not a mistake to ask the screenwriter, “How can we do this differently?” It is a mistake to say quite arrogantly, “Some of this isn’t important.” It is as much a mistake as it would be to open up a human body during surgery, grab a hold of some little gibbet and go, “This probably doesn’t mean anything,” and just pull it out because we put things in on purpose. Then, of course, what happens is three or four weeks later, you might get a call like, “This doesn’t make sense.” Yes, well, because you took that thing out and you didn’t realize because you hadn’t lived in it the way I did.
When you want to change things in a screenplay, and it’s perfectly fine to say, “Look, we’re changing it. We must change it for the following reasons, even if one of the reasons is my directorial taste. Tell me, how can I change this so that I don’t hurt anything?” First, do no harm. That’s what I want from a director more than anything else in terms of how they interact with me. That involves, obviously, a certain amount of respect and acknowledgement that the screenplay isn’t just a suggestion or even a blueprint, which I’ve never understood, but rather is a conceptualized movie.
John: What I’m looking for in a director is someone who can come in and channel this vision of a movie onto the screen. It’s really a person who can experience the movie internally and then has the skills to be able to put that up on a screen. That is such a unique skill set. There are people who are just amazingly good at it. You can do things that I would just never think of to do. That’s what gets me so excited is when you see a director who can just do these amazing things. I cannot underscore enough is that I don’t want this person to make my script.
I want this person to make my movie and make her version of my movie. I want that movie to be fantastic. When there are suggestions or changes or concerns or things they don’t like, that’s awesome. Let’s talk those through, but don’t try to change them on the set without getting some feedback because, yes, everything that’s in the script was there for a reason. There was a reason why this whole carefully constructed puzzle fits together one way. There’s other ways it could be assembled, but there was one way it was supposed to work. If you can talk with me about that beforehand, that’s awesome.
In those first conversations, a lot of those first conversations with the director is basically just talking through the whole movie so I get a sense of what the movie looks like in the director’s head. Sometimes that really does mean, as a screenwriter, I’m explaining scenes, and I wrote it, and now I’m actually talking through the whole explanation of it, but it’s so important that we be on the same page, literally the same page written, but also the same idea about what the intentions are of those scenes. The times where things have gone not especially well have been cases where the director really thought the scene was about something completely different than what I thought the scene was about.
It’s fine for us to have a difference of opinion, but we didn’t even have a difference of opinion. He just shot a different scene than what it meant that scene to be, and then that scene no longer shows up in the movie and there’s problems.
Craig: Absolutely true. The other thing that I think the perfect director exhibits is patience. Now, I’ve said this before many times: directing a movie, a feature film, is the hardest job in show business. Directors cannot be patient with everybody. In fact, most directors really have only a very tiny amount of patience that they reserve entirely for their actors. They must be patient with their actors because if they yell at their actors or are impatient with their actors, they’re getting bad performances. Of course, this is all about what they’re getting on screen from their human beings, unless they’re all computer-generated robots.
I would ask the perfect director to extend that patience to actors to writers, that we need actually the same amount of patience. The reason I say that is not because we’re sensitive flowers, but rather because you will get a better movie if you’re patient with the screenwriter. Frankly, there are a lot of directors who are least patient with the screenwriter. They find the screenwriter and the screenplay to be this offensive reminder that this world that they’re creating is not entirely their world. It’s disruptive of their confidence. I understand that. There are screenwriters who get fussy about changes.
The perfect director is patient with the screenwriter because they will get better work, and they will make a better movie if they are. I always tell my fellow screenwriters to be patient in return to the director. They need us at our best in order to survive, and we are all in the same boat of trying to make a good movie. A good director is patient with the screenwriter.
John: You talk about how incredibly hard the director’s job is. I completely agree. It’s like you’re a general leading your troops into battle. The crucial thing is that you have to have the trust of your troops. Your crew has to trust and believe that you have a vision for how you’re going to win this fight, how you’re going to succeed in doing this thing. That means that you had a lot of planning. You really knew what you were going to do ahead of time. You were able to read the lay of the land and see, “Okay, on the day we’ve arrived at this location. This location is different than how I had expected it to be. I’m flexible enough to roll with what needs to actually happen.”
The directors who are inflexible, who everything has to be exactly the way they had storyboarded it, are not going to be able to roll with the changes and roll with the punches. The great directors can also recognize and really remember the intention of the scene. If an improved moment comes up that’s actually better than what was there, they will be able to incorporate it and be able to both have the version of the scene as it existed, but also recognize this new version is better, funnier, more dramatic. It does something unique and wonderful. I’m so glad I’m going to have that in the editing room as well.
Craig: That reminds me, just another bit of advice going backwards for Matthew Chilelli as he approaches his first movie. A good director leads the crew but also understands that the crew will not be able to tell her or him that they’re making a good movie. All the crew sees are dailies. That’s what they see. They see live dailies going on. They may see funny moments, and they may see an actor do a hysterical thing or a beautiful thing. As the old saying goes, there’s nothing better than your dailies, and there’s nothing worse than your first cut. They don’t know what the movie is.
John: They don’t.
Craig: Don’t ask them what they think, and don’t be encouraged or discouraged if they offer their opinions. No one, except for you and your editor, has any sense, really, of the movie that is going to result. You’re the only ones that have seen the completed jigsaw puzzle. You’re just making pieces now, right? Don’t overreact to that whole thing. In comedy, we called it a daily’s laugh, where the crew just goes, “Oh my God,” and they’ll come up to you at lunch, “That was so funny.” In your heart, you know, “It’s getting cut out of the movie.” There’s something about those moments, those moments that are so funny in the moment, so often just do not live in the matrix of the put-together film.
John: Any last bits of summary for our perfect director? I would say there’s not one perfect archetype for a director. I’ve worked with directors who I love, who are vastly different from each other. That’s fine. That’s okay. They all have different ways of communicating their vision to their department heads and to me and to everybody else who has to see what it is. Sometimes it’s not immediately clear to me. I have no idea what you’re doing, but it all works. The directors who I admire as a viewer, I don’t necessarily know what they’re like on the set, but if people are working with them again and again, there’s probably something that they’re doing that’s really, really good.
They’re probably treating their crews with respect. They’re probably able to communicate what it is that they’re trying to do so people can do their very best jobs. They’re able to inspire the best work out of people. That’s how you make great movies.
Craig: Yes. I think that, frankly, the best directors, the directors that I love, as I run down the list in my mind, they’re either writers or they really respect writers. The directors that I find ultimately are disposable, who disappear, or who just make stuff I don’t like are directors that are notorious for not giving a crap about the script, that the script is a, “Ha, ha, ha, I’m a director.”
Flashback: Advice for a First Feature
↑ Back to Top
MUSIC – SECOND FLASHBACK SEGMENT:
John: This is from Scott, who’s asking about his first feature.
Scott: I just got my first feature film greenlit to the tune of a few million dollars. It’s a horror movie I adapted from a book, funded through a private investor, and I’m both thrilled and terrified. What advice do you have for a first-time filmmaker jumping in at this level to avoid royally flooding this? I’m also curious about setting expectations for the finished film. What should I be thinking about now to ensure the finished film is what I have in my head? Finally, as it moves into the marketplace, are there any insights to avoid getting screwed over?
John: I hear Scott asking a series of questions. Basically, I hear him asking, how do I emotionally protect myself from what I know is going to be a difficult situation? I hear him asking, how do I make sure I make the best movies and don’t screw things up? I feel like there’s probably some imposter syndrome also embedded in all this as well. First off, congratulations. Great news. Great that you’re able to find money to make this thing. That’s fantastic.
Craig: Absolutely.
John: This investor is great, but you need to have somebody who actually knows what the hell they’re doing. You’ll need a line producer, but you also need a producer on board who has made this kind of film at this kind of budget level and sold this kind of film at this kind of budget level, because it’s such a specific thing. I know people who’ve literally fallen into a bunch of money and made a movie, and they’re like, “I got to make the movie I wanted to make,” and they had no plan for how to put it out there in the world. That is disastrous.
Craig: Scott, I feel your fear, which is completely justified. [chuckles] I have felt it myself. I’ll try and be comforting, and then I’m going to give you the anti-comfort. The comforting part is there are some simple things that you can keep in mind as you go through this. The first is, don’t expect that anybody is going to respect you when you start doing this. In fact, quite the opposite. People are very suspicious of first-time directors. The crews just presume that you’re going to suck and you’re not going to know what you’re doing. You’re going to want to really get a good relationship with your first AD.
The first AD is the person that’s going to help you move through your day. They’re going to keep you planned. You’re going to want to have an excellent relationship with your cinematographer because the first AD and the cinematographer, pushing and pulling, will have the biggest impact on how long your day is and how much you get done that day. You’re going to want to create a little bit of a bubble for yourself and the actors because they’re the ones who end up on screen. You’re going to want to have a good relationship with the crew, but don’t be overly concerned if the crew doesn’t like the show itself, the movie. That’s not important.
What’s important is that you have some sort of vision for it because you’re gathering pieces that you’ll put together later. Those things, good stuff. Then keep in mind that there will be politics going on that will swirl around you, and try to ignore them as best you can. If somebody gives you constructive criticism about how you can get more out of people or do a better job, listen to it carefully, take it in, be humble. Don’t get caught up in swirling political stuff between actors, between representatives, between the money and the producer, any of that stuff.
Now let me be uncomforting. There is nothing we can tell you that is going to prepare you for this. You are not going to be the same person when you’re finished. You will be smarter, you will know more, and you will be better when you’re finished. This is not good news because it means that you are not going to be the best you can be when you start. This is normal. It’s just normal. Go in there understanding that you’re going to do your best, but you are going to grow and improve from this experience. You cannot foresaw these things. There’s no way to prepare for a lot of it. It’s a little bit like having a baby. You can read a whole lot of books, but when you have the baby, you’re like, “Oh, no.”
There will be some days, man. There’ll be some days, but it’s okay. Everybody who’s been a successful filmmaker has gone through this.
John: Here’s my pitch. Making a film is a creative heist. Think about it like it’s a heist. It’s like Ocean’s Eleven. How do you pull off a heist? First off, you have to assemble a team. Assembling that team is crucial. You’ve got to have the right people on board to make this with you. That is, you’ve mentioned the first AD. Cinematographer, I think, is right up there at the tip top. That is the person you’re going to be sharing a vision for is what it is you’re actually seeing on screen. Your production designer, your editor, your casting director, and ultimately your cast, that is the crew that you’re assembling to pull off this creative heist.
Then you’re going to have a plan. You’re going to have a really detailed plan. If everything goes exactly according to plan, you’re going to make the best movie. It’s all going to work perfectly, but it’s not. That’s why you need to have a crew that you really can trust and smart people for when things don’t go according to plan. Your job is to be able to remember what is important because you wrote the script, which is great, but that script and reality are not going to match up very well. You’re going to have to have situations where, okay, we have lost this location. What do we do? You’re going to have to be the person who figures out what to do in those situations.
That’s by really understanding what those scenes are about. Therefore, if you have to set it someplace else or if you lose this actor or whatever else, you make it work. Especially filmmaking at this budget level where you don’t have the kind of padding and safeties; that’s the reality.
Craig: You aren’t going to make the movie that you have in your mind right now. That’s not possible. You will hopefully make a movie that represents enough of what you had in mind and has the essence of what you were looking for, but you are going to constantly be wavering back and forth between not wanting to be too precious so that you can solve problems and make your days, but also not wanting to be too much of a good boy syndrome.
John: Obliging is not going to help anybody.
Craig: Yes, exactly. You have to figure out how to wander that middle ground. It’s tough. You may miss a few times. You may go too far one way or the other. AD, cinematographer, start there. Those two people are incredibly important. If you run into people like production designer or costume designer, anybody that you suspect is just there to get paid, and I’m talking about department heads, putting aside the pure crafts like grip and electric. When we’re talking about the creative department heads, if they seem like they don’t care, they’re not right for this. You need people that care. You want them to actually be passionate about this. There’s no way to get through it otherwise.
John: I’m helping out with a movie that shoots this fall, and seeing the director assemble her team has just been so inspiring because she has such a specific, unique, singular vision. She will meet with 15 people, and it’ll be the 16th person like, “That’s the one,” and she’s right.
Craig: That’s nice.
John: [chuckles] It’s also the luxury of being able to shoot in town and having choices like that.
Craig: Exactly.
John: The last thing, Craig said, you can read as much as you want to read about it. What would be probably helpful for you, Scott, right now is to read accounts of filmmakers who’ve done something recently and who did things at your budget level and what they learned, what they would have done differently. Read those interviews if there are longer-form books, or just stuff, because that’s the kind of stuff– you’re entering into a very specific kind of filmmaking, and to understand how that works is going to really serve you.
Craig: I think there’s a book called My First Time.
John: Oh, yes, there is a book.
Craig: It’s a collection of interviews with directors about their first time directing. I remember reading it thinking, “This is great.” The whole point of the book, it was pitched like, “Okay, if you read this, then you can avoid the mistakes that all these great directors made.” No, you can’t. You’re going to make your own mistakes, and you’ll be too worried about making their mistakes, and it’ll be too artificial and weird. You got to be yourself.
John: You also recognize that all these people made these mistakes, and they’re now fantastic directors.
Craig: Exactly, and so you’re just going to have to experience this, and it’s going to be a wild ride. I will say, once you do it and you come out the other end, you will look at movies and television in a much different and vastly more forgiving way.
John: I remember when I was making The Nines, leading up to The Nines, before I brought on my cinematographer, I got way too obsessed with cameras. Then I realized I should not be thinking about the camera at all. It’s out of my purview. I should let the cinematographer decide what she wants to do for this. I can give her poetic descriptions of what I’m going for, but let them decide this.
Craig: Ksenia Sereda, who’s our cinematographer on The Last of Us, before the second season, she was so excited. She’s like, “Okay, I’m getting these special lenses that are going to be made for this season with this cool thing going on.” She tried to explain to me, and I didn’t understand. She goes, “Don’t worry. I’m going to shoot a bunch of tests. I’m going to show you all these different things, and you’ll see the differences.” I’m like, “Great.” Then she showed them all to me, and I was like, “These all look great. Which one is the one that you want?” She’s like, “This one.” I’m like, “Okie dokie,” because I don’t need to know.
She was like, “Look,” because it’s like, okay, the test footage is just some light bulbs turned up in a room. She’s like, “These will be great for these scenes, and here’s why.” I was like, “Okay, I trust you on that stuff.” When makeup people are like, “Here’s how we’re going to approach this,” I’m like, “Great,” because I don’t do that. You do need to trust your people. They will come to you with a million questions. Be prepared to answer four million questions a day.
John: That’s the reason why I didn’t want to direct for a while, which is like, “Ooh, I think they’re going to ask me 1,000 questions a day; I won’t have the answers.” Then I was like, “Oh, no, I do have the answers.”
Craig: You will. In fact, what’s frustrating is sometimes you’re like, “I thought that was obvious from this. Okay, let me explain [unintelligible 00:41:37] Of course, everybody who works on The Last of Us knows that I love meetings where the question that was asked 14 times gets asked the 15th time.
John: I think podcast listeners have heard you talk about this many times, too.
Craig: Oh, yes. You know what? I get it. I answer it.
Flashback: Eva Victor on Directing
↑ Back to Top
MUSIC – THIRD FLASHBACK SEGMENT:
John: Eva, I thought that was a good jumping-off point to talk about artistry frequently is indistinguishable from persistence because that is the thing about filmmaking is that you can say, “Oh my God, that was an amazing movie.” It’s like, “Yes, but it wasn’t just brilliant because it was brilliant because the person had this great idea. It was so much hard work day after day, year after year to get things done.” I think it’s the thing we talk about a lot on the show. As I went through my career and as I’ve met and worked with some great directors, it’s just been always such a revelation. It’s like, “Oh, you’re just working really, really hard.”
I think it’s a thing that’s just underappreciated, especially as we get into sometimes award seasons and you think, “Oh my God, this is a person of genius, not person of genius.” It’s like, “No, they’re just working really hard.” There’s luck, and there’s all these things. There is talent, but it’s all these things. I want to maybe frame some of our conversation with you around this because you came up, you have some experience, but as I’m reading through the press notes on this, you wrote the script not even necessarily intending to direct it. Can you talk us through the journey to this is a script and now this is a script that I’m going to try to direct?
Eva Victor: Yes, totally. I think that theme is very relevant for me. I feel like there was a moment that I realized my career would never be made by somebody else. It picked me up out of oblivion and gave me an amazing role that was the big role for my– there was this realization of you are the one who has to get you where you want to go. I have always been like, “I’m not going to fail because I don’t work hard. I’m going to fail because I’m missing some intrinsic quality that people have.” I was like, “It’s never going to be because I don’t put in the hours.” That discipline has kept me from, I think, mentally losing my mind.
It’s like, “Well, what can I control? I can write more. I can study. I can watch films. I can get my day job to a place where I’m making enough, so I have these hours. I had a development deal with the studio that happened because of my internet videos. That was a very difficult experience because I was turning in page-one drafts for, honestly, years, thinking that if I just wrote the perfect draft, then I would get the momentum and attention from the [sound cut] I needed to make that film happen, but that didn’t come. That made me lose my goddamn mind. It made me really internalize something about I am fraudulent. I can’t do this. I’m not meant to write.
Then I wrote scripts for a body horror thing that didn’t make sense, but it had a lot of heart. I sent that around to people through my agents at the time. My rejections were very impersonal no’s. The one person I’d met before I sent this script who read it and said no, but the rejection letter meant everything, was Pastel, Barry Jenkins Company. When I met Barry, he was like, “Your videos,” which I was, even at that point, ashamed of or whatever. He was like, “It’s filmmaking. It’s just not the way that other people do it. It’s a small version, but you are directing this. You’re making decisions about how people look, where the camera’s going, and what people are saying.”
I think that gave me this optimism, or like, “Oh, man, someone sees the hard work behind this.” Then when I sent them the script, they said a very generous no and made this really beautiful letter about the script and what was valuable about it emotionally. Then why they weren’t the right partners for it. That was weirdly a letter that I read and cried out of like, “Oh, but there are people out there who are understanding.” Then I had, over the course of five years or so, been stewing on the idea for Sorry, Baby, but was like, “Man, the words, if I start writing them down too soon just for this particular project, I’m going to get too depressed about how bad it is compared to what the story means to me.”
It took me a really long time to piece together the writing of it. Then finally, I sat myself down in a cabin in Maine and was like, “It’s time. You’re writing this.” I wrote it and sent it to Pastel again because I was like, “They get me.” They were like, “Okay, what do you dream of for this?” I was like, “I’m going to act in it,” dot, dot, dot, dot, dot, hoping that–
John: I want to clarify, at this point, you are an actor who’s been cast in things independently because you have acting credits. It’s not crazy to think that you’re going to be acting this.
Eva: Right. It’s not crazy because it is a different thing.
Craig: Yes, but there’s that concern that, oh, well, if we had Jennifer Lawrence, then maybe we would get the blah, blah, blah, and you’re like, “No, it’s going to be me.”
Eva: It was very clear that when I’m the lead actor, that means that the film is this big.
Craig: This big.
Eva: I was like, “I’m willing to sacrifice whatever thing that is.”
John: Eva, can I ask you about the script that you sent to Pastel? Does it closely resemble the movie that Ashley’s made? The footprint of the film is very small. It’s a cabin in the woods. While the times are shifting around it, the actual literal geography it’s inhabiting is very, very small. Was it always that way?
Eva: Yes, it was always that small. It’s very, very similar to the script that we shot. There are some changes. Mainly, I did a little work with Pastel around the character of Lydie. Then once we got Naomi, that opened it up for me of how this person talks. There were just a few scenes that we adjusted the dialogue. I have not had this since, and I don’t know if I will, how little we had to work on the script. What do you think?
Craig: I think you worked on the script a lot. I think that what people sometimes think is that all the work on the script happens after the “first draft”, which is never really a first draft. Some people do write first drafts, but a lot of people hand a script over that they have been– you’ve been thinking about it for years. Then when you went to your Stephen King cabin, what came out was something that was already thought through. There was an enormous amount of intention and structure and care and thought, I suspect, having seen the movie and having seen the way you directed it, that you had already directed the movie in your head. You saw it.
You saw it, you heard it. You felt it. You smelled it. It’s all there. It’s okay for that work to happen earlier. I think it’s the best thing. I think it’s why people say yes. There’s a certain kind of movie that you can write that’s about, “Oh my God, the aliens are crashing to the moon,” and you can figure that shit out as you go. For this, what I was so impressed by was how seamless the writing and the direction was. You are a walking billboard for what I think should be the gold standard for how we make feature films: a writer-director.
I just feel like even though there’s a conspiracy to convince all of us that somehow directing is this unattainable thing as opposed to writing, which we can all kind of do, no, it’s not. You’re doing it already.
Eva: There is so many layers of the reasons why I didn’t think I would want to direct it that all have to do with not understanding what the job is, and you can learn things to do a job. That you’re not born with information, even though it feels like you are. The college I went to, I never had any interest in directing. It was mostly plays where I went. I had no interest because I was like, “Well, this kind of guy does that, and that kind of looks this way and talks this way, and I don’t want to be in charge like that because I’m not compelled to be him. It’s like, “Oh, I have my own way of doing that,” and it took a bit of soul-searching to realize, “Oh my God, I’m desperate to direct this. I know how it looks and feels. I need to hire geniuses around me to help me find the words for visual language.” It was a lot of, “I don’t know, but I want to do it.” I think I don’t know is so awesome.
Craig: Best words.
Eva: You’re allowed to make your first movie. You’re allowed to be doing something for the first time because you have to do it. I really fell in love with also– What was reassuring to me was the process of collecting images and moments and pieces, almost like a little scrapbook of information, was a very enjoyable private process of building a world. I felt, as the work of director unfolded and I discovered what it was as I was doing it, each part of it felt like a miracle. At one point in the edit, I was like, “Thank fucking God I like this, but I love it, and I need it. Thank God, because otherwise, why would you ever, ever put yourself through this deeply intense experience that lasts forever?”
Craig: It lasts forever and every day lasts forever, but also is way too short. It’s this nightmare of time that is never enough and is yet too much. I just feel like you’ve put your finger on something incredibly important, which is we all have a sense, whether we’ve learned it from school or from culture, of the kind of person director should be. A kind of person a director should be is a man, and he is a big– He’s Michael Bay. Basically, in my mind, that’s what I have.
John: They have a big personality, yes.
Craig: It’s Michael Bay, and I am not Michael Bay. I will never be Michael Bay. I don’t have whatever that is. That’s not me, or Ridley Scott. I’m also not that. I am an ink-stained wretch, but ink-stained wretches are also wonderful directors. I love that you overcame the internalized image because I honestly think that’s the thing that hurts us the most, is we just start with a belief that we’re not.
Eva: Yes. Trust me, now it’s a different issue, but that one, I overcame. I’m not going to get through that, but I’m like, now, because the writing of this film, now my experience of it is nostalgia for a time when I now remember it as flow. I don’t think it was. I toiled over that script. It was just I sent it when I was done with it. Now I’m like, “Oh, yes, directing, whatever, but writing, you guys. This needs oil. This is squeaky or something because it’s been so long. Now there’s eyes on me.” I thought the most painful thing was not having–
Craig: It’s the worst thing.
Eva: It’s the worst. Then this is also like, yes. I’m like, “Okay, now you’re trying to kill me by celebrating my film?”
John: “How dare you say yes?” Yes.
Eva: Just be honest, but also be nice. I’ve made a film. There’s so much. I only know how to make that film. It’s a mind fuck.
John: Yes, it is. Can we rewind and talk about how you learned to make that film? That’s what’s so useful for so many of our listeners is that you have a script and you have people say like, “We agree you should direct this. Now learn how to direct a film.” What did you assign yourself? What did other people send you to look at? What’s the process?
Eva: You know what? Yes. This I would love to talk about. First off, was like, “Okay, you didn’t go to film school, so there’s a lot of fraudulence around not knowing things about film.” Like, “If I learn lenses? We’ll be good.” Encyclopedic, ordering the books from film school, reading the books from film school. Research that was very dry, but I was like, “Let’s just read this. Let’s put post-its through it.” Quickly realized like, “Okay, this is simply information that actually I need. It was kind of a process of constantly being like, “Okay, that fills that need. Now, what is missing, still?” Then it became, “I need to watch a million movies.” I’d been watching movies, which is why I wrote a movie, but I was like, “I need to watch films and then, as I’m watching them, not fall into watching them, instead watch them.”
John: Look at them, study them, pull them apart. Yes. See what they’re doing.
Eva: Exactly. I became very into backwards shot listing films. A photo of every setup and blending them up and understanding when we return to the same set. It was very mathematical. When are we returning to the same setup? How long are we on Laura Dern’s face in Certain Women before we get to his face? Why? I became more aware of my taste. I was like, “Oh, I like the economy of not thinking until we have to–” I became aware of what the film was needing from a visual standpoint. I was backwards shot listing and would write out the shot list. Obviously, it’s not a complete picture because you never know what someone left out, but you get a sense of how cohesive vocabulary is built in a film.
Certain Women was a really helpful one for me. That is like a three-part. There was chapters to that film, and they’re related. How do you make three women who are strangers become related? Then I created a shot list for my film, which, instead of shot listing, because that felt random, I drew storyboards of everything. By the way, I had ample time. Man, fill your day with some shit to do because no one is knocking right now. We were just taking our time. It was drawing everything and every frame of the film. You could go through the storyboard and watch the film, which some of the shots are really what is in the storyboard.
Then obviously, some very important changes were made in collaboration with my DP, Mia, who making decisions for good reasons later on. It was like an instinctual storyboard, like, “What is the first thing that feels right?” Then I shadowed my friend Jane Schoenbrun on I Saw the TV Glow. I was like, “Oh, I’m ready. I’m not ready, but I’m ready to start being ready.” I’d been on set as an actor, but on set as an actor, it’s like, “Come in, and do you need water? Do you need Diet Coke? You’re good for the day. Good job.”
I find acting very stressful in moments, especially when you’re there for some time, but not the whole time, because it’s so vulnerable, but it is a different experience of things are hidden from you to protect you, which I feel complicated about, but whatever. Some things are just not your job to know. When you’re on set sitting behind a director with nothing to do on the set besides watch that person, you realize how different people advocate for their film and the different styles of how people advocate, but also how a film is built moment to moment in very– It’s non-miraculous. It’s like by the end of the shoot, you have the pieces to go to the kitchen. Mixy metaphors is okay, I guess.
That was my stuff. Then what you do is you take meetings with different heads of department and through– They made a lookbook. Actually, I’m going to make a lookbook in return, and then you have a conversation with image, and then you become specific. The cool thing about directing a film is you make decisions every day over time. The film was built over time. That was reassuring to me too because at first you’re alone, but then you bring people in, and it’s not just yours, and that’s a relief really to like, “Okay, you got that character thing, fucking God, that’s yours. Say it how you want to say it.”
Craig: Well, I think that what you just said from start to finish is, I’m going to use the word probably because I want to be kind and charitable to film schools, it is probably worth more than four years of film school. What you just laid out there, in part, because you just belied the need for film school. You taught yourself what you needed to learn. I love that. I went through the same thing because I didn’t go to film school. There’s a special technical film school for directing, which you didn’t go to, and I didn’t go to, but we’re smart.
We read stuff quickly and learned things quickly. The thing about lenses, I don’t need a semester on lenses. I need 30 minutes on lenses to get the basic breakdown of it. Then I need to be on set and go, “Can we try something longer?” The cinematographer’s like, “Yes, you know what, 50. Let’s go.” Then you’re like, “Oh my God, that’s the thing.” You start to get muscle memory. All of these things you laid out. The way you storyboarded, the way you broke things down.
John: Reverse shot listing is so crucial.
Craig: Shot listing is genius. That’s genius.
John: I want to just pause for a second because people may not quite know what we’re describing. You’re watching a scene in a movie, and you can figure out, “Okay, well, we are a close-up of her or a close-up of her, but there’s also a two-shot, and there seems to be a wider shot.” You can basically figure out what were the actual shots they had on the day to make that thing. That was the plan going into it. Then you can also look at, “How do they actually use it? When do they move into coverage? When do they stay wide?” All the information is right there. You can see it because it’s in the film. That is so, so useful. Part of this is reminding me of people who watch Drag Race.
There’s bedroom queens who do really good drag at home, and they’re on Instagram and stuff like that. There’s also, obviously, queens need to go out and actually perform in front of other people. That, to me, is the transition from you shot listing at home and then going to a set and seeing Jane directly on the set for her movie because you are watching like, “Oh, this is what it’s actually really like. This is what the actual decisions look like in the field, where it’s not just–” It can’t be perfect on Instagram. You’re making choices moment by moment.
I’m sure you found this. Craig, I know you’ve encountered this. When you are on a set, and it’s not your movie, you’re still watching the monitor, and you have so many opinions. He’s like, “I can’t believe we’re moving on. There’s no way that’s going to cut right. That’s not what it is.” You recognize, “No, but the director knows what they need. They know, ‘Okay, between these two things, they know what’s important.'”
Craig: Sometimes.
John: Sometimes. Craig’s also a show writer who obviously does have control of a film.
Craig: Every now and again, they go, “Okay, we’re moving on.” I go, “No, we’re not.”
Eva: Declaring we’re moving on is like, well, that’s crazy. You can’t really go back on moving on. Okay, you have to be sure.
Craig: My thing on moving on is before I move on, I check with the tent. Who’s in the tent? My script supervisor is in the tent, and a producer is in the tent. My assistant is in the tent. People who have been watching this. I’m like, “Are we feeling okay about this? We’re good? Do you think we got it?” “Yes, I feel like we got it.” “Okay, moving on.” You’re absolutely right. It’s like an abandonment. It’s the worst part of directing, is that you have to do more than you have time to do. You move at such speed, but you do get better as you go. You were, I assume, a much better director a week– I don’t know how many weeks you shot for. Let’s say five, four?
Eva: 24 days.
Craig: Five weeks. Week five, you were a better director than week one. Almost certainly.
Eva: Definitely. You know what? You don’t really self-reflect like that. Then Naomi was there the whole time. She was there the first day, and she was there the second to last day. She was like, “Bitch, what the hell?” She was so proud of me. I was like, “You know what? It’s so true.” You know what? There was actually something else I wanted to add, which was a really pivotal part of my building the film two years, was we did shoot two scenes from the film in a very small–
Me and my DP and a group of my DP’s students at NYU came to shoot in an Airbnb in New York where we both lived. Two scenes. The prompt for my producers was, “Who produced it?” It was a practice setting. The prompt was, “Two scenes that scare you.” I did a scene that was terrifying for me to direct because I didn’t understand the mechanics of the movement of the people, the mode of movement. Then the other one was as an actor, this scene in the bathtub where Agnes tells Lydie what happened.
John: It’s a Sundance Labs thing. That’s exactly what you do. Yes.
Eva: Exactly. Then I worked with an editor, Kate Broca, who– That was the moment when I was like, “Oh, you cannot cut from a Y to a Y.”
Craig: Love this.
Eva: I’m like, “Oh, man, what a master class in failure. I didn’t really realize it was a test, but then there was this moment when they were like, “What would you have changed about how you shot it?” That was the moment when they were like, “Okay, yes, you understand what you would change.” Also, shadowing a set is very interesting because I shadowed a couple days on Billions, the show that I was on, just to watch those directors. The budget of that shoot is one real particular thing. The vocabulary of the show is very, very heavily covered. We go over every shoulder, clean. We do everything.
Then Jane’s film was a particular budget that was much larger than the budget I was going to have, but to go backwards, to get a sense of scope and how much can you get done in a day when you have more days, when you have less days, when you have an actor who can only be there three day– Just to get a sense of a few different things, to understand that things on your set will be particular to your set.
Craig: I think you did a fantastic job. It’s funny. I was watching through, and I was noticing, first of all, I have a particular– It’s just taste. It’s not that I don’t like when people move cameras around. I just don’t like it when cameras move around for no fucking reason. I like a camera to be still, and I like the people to move around. I loved how still it was so frequently. I noted, as I was watching, how many scenes didn’t really seem to need coverage. You had a nice two-shot, and it worked that way. That’s how the characters were interacting, and it was great. The scene that I was like, “There’s one that was probably tricky,” was when Decker and all of his grad students are around a table. Shooting around a table is a nightmare. I’d rather shoot a car chase than a scene with that many people around a table.
Eva: That makes me feel better because I’m like, “How do you fucking shoot a car chase?” Would never break that–
Craig: It turns out it’s because you can edit the shit out of car chases, but the eye lines around a table, that’s nightmare stuff for me. You did it really well.
Eva: Thank you. There are a few mistakes in the film, continuity issues, and one of them is in that scene. I’ll never say what it is. Okay, you just have to live with the fact that that happened. I think, honestly, Billions prepared me for that. Also, so much of understanding a scene is like, “Who is the scene about?” His special attention to Agnes. It’s like, “That helps.” These boys can be in a two-shot, like a three-shot. They will be cut to highlight that this is less vulnerable.
Craig: Then you got to explain that to them. Sometimes actors don’t like that.
Eva: No, no, no. They’re my close friends, so they kind of understood.
Craig: Yes, it’s a tricky one.
Script Directions and a Listener Question
↑ Back to Top
John: All right, we’re back here. It is now September 2026. Lauren is preparing to direct your short film. Do you have a start date? Do you know when you’re going to shoot this?
Eva: We are planning on shooting it in November.
John: Right. What was your main takeaway from the clips that you gave us?
Eva: My main takeaways were, do your homework and be steadfast in your vision.
Craig: Yes. You mentioned that this one’s going to have more visual effects. Do you have somebody that is your visual effects supervisor?
Eva: We do not have that person yet, but we are definitely going to have that person.
Craig: That person is your co-director because what I have found over the course of doing a show with a lot of visual effects is, in the end, they’re the ones who have to take all the pieces that you’ve gathered and then do the work. There are things they’re going to need. There are lighting considerations they have that the DP might not necessarily take into account.
There are some frames that you would think would be beautiful, and they’re like, “Except for this and this, they have to be there.” You have to check with them on those shots all the time. Above all, make sure they get what they need. The balls and charts and the clean plates and whatever it is, give them anything they want. They are like your special little kid that gets everything.
John: Lauren, any other questions or things that we didn’t get to in these previous things? What else is on your mind?
Eva: You touched on it a little bit, but my main question for both of you is, does the anxiety ever go away?
Craig: Yes. When you get tired enough, then it’s just exhaustion. Oh, yes, the anxiety is replaced by depression. That’s what I probably should have said.
John: Craig, you’ve had a chance to direct a ton on Last of Us. Does the daily anxiety go away where you’re like, “No, okay, I’ve got this?”
Craig: Yes. There is an anxiety that you have early on, which is, “I will not know what to do tomorrow.” You think it through really carefully. You get into your shot list. You get into your things. You stress over it and mull over it. Then when you get there, you may find yourself a bit rigidly devoted to it. Over time, you trust that, in fact, it is good to have a plan and then let it go as the day emerges because things will happen. If you’re scheduled the way I suspect you will be, when you don’t have a big budget, and you have a lot to do every day, there’s no time to be anxious.
The only anxiety I usually feel during the day is the pressure of time. That never goes away because that’s just a fact. You’re in that garbage compressor in Star Wars. It’s just getting closer and closer to you. The moment you start, you’re behind. You obviously lean on a good first AD to help give you a sense of how you’re doing. When something’s not working, you know it’s not quite right. You need the time to make it better, but you’re running out of time. Oh, buddy. That’s when it gets fun.
John: I would say that there’s preparation and there’s intention. So often, we were all great [unintelligible 01:10:10], we’re all good planners; we’re all good students. You make a very detailed plan, but remember that the plan is not the actual scene. As you enter these situations, always be able to go back to, “What is my actual intention for this scene? What is important about the scene? Am I achieving that?” Because as you’re necessarily pivoting based on reality, you can still go to, like, “Is it achieving the needs of the scene even though my original plan didn’t work out?”
Craig: As a director, I’m quite different as a writer. As you know, as a writer, I’m very plan-heavy. I love a big, super detailed treatment. When I write the script, I allow myself to do whatever I want, but it’s within the pre-thought confines of what it should be. As a director, I really try to not do any of that. As a director, I honestly try to show up in the morning because I’ve written it; I try to be as blank of a slate as I can and be as improvisational as I can.
A nice first thing to do right after call, little private blocking, read the scene out loud. Just read it out loud with everybody. You do the stage directions, they do the lines, you all read it together. This way, if there’s anything you’ve written down that you might have– You will forget your own things that you wrote down in between the dialogue. It’s there.
Then see how it goes, because sometimes, you’re going to want to go– There was a scene we were doing the other day, and there was this bit of action into it, and there were so many things about it that were not working. The more I tried to solve the problem, the more depressed that we got. Then, I came to the best solution of all, which is to get rid of it. Then, everything was fine. You have to be open to receiving what you’re getting. Work with what you have. You’ll do great as you did before. You’ll do great again.
John: We’re looking forward to seeing the first terrible cut and the finished product.
Eva: Thank you.
Craig: It might be a great first cut.
Eva: It might be a great– Yes.
Craig: You never know.
John: You never know.
Craig: You never know. Well, we’ll never see the terrible cut.
John: We’ll never see the first terrible cut.
Craig: No.
Eva: I’m not showing you that.
John: No.
Craig: No. What’s the point? I don’t want to watch it. I want to watch the good one.
John: All right, let’s answer a listener question that is related to this. Meredith, what do you got for us?
Meredith: “Dear John and Craig, I’ve been a listener and a fan of the show since film school in London more than a decade ago. As a writer-director in Norway still trying to realize my first long-form project, one of my biggest inspirations is the work of Paul Thomas Anderson. I recently read his script for There Will Be Blood, and although there’s a ton of visual directing on the page, as you have aptly defended over the years, there is very little directing of the actors on the page, apart from clean dialogue and concrete movement or spatial orientation when strictly necessary.
Little, if any, parentheticals, italics, underlining, or scene descriptions directly suggesting how actors should do their job. He talked about this in an interview, and it’s been a very conscious thing about his style of writing, as he always felt actors preferred it that way, giving them more room. I remember getting that note indirectly from an experienced actress when I was writing for another director in film school. How much can you tighten things and leave between the lines before you remove too much?
All the best from Oslo, Norway.”
John: I understand this question because you want to make sure that the actors feel empowered to make choices, and they’re not animation characters who are being guided through the path this way. The reason why you sometimes provide very specific descriptions of how characters are playing the moments is because, before it gets in front of actors, a ton of other people need to actually read and understand the script and understand what the actual scenes are like and what they feel like. Sometimes that does mean giving specific reactions, sometimes parentheticals, other things, so that the reader can play the character in their mind and get a sense of what it feels like. You could take those out before you start shooting if it’s helpful. Craig?
Craig: Everyone approaches this differently. I will say that Paul Thomas Anderson’s method of making Paul Thomas Anderson movies is flawless, and that’s all that matters for him and how he does it. I tend to provide as much subtext as I can, but not in parentheses, and not in a manner of, “This is what you’re feeling,” or saying, “She starts to sweat because she remembers this.”
I will do it as dialogue, which forces me to think in terms of ways people will feel things, and I’ll put that in the action. I don’t really do parentheticals much, except for “Beat,” and maybe something like, “Wait, what?” I’ll do that maybe. Again, sort of subtextual, because it’s all information. The dialogue is information, the subtext is information, and there are times where, if you don’t have it there, an actor might simply not know what you were going for.
On the one hand, with words, sometimes directors will err on the side of saying, “I’m going to give as little as possible.” But those same directors, of course, will also talk about the essential nature of the director’s vision, which implies the opposite, which is to say, “I know what I want, and this is-” It’s a balance. There are actors who want to get as little as possible because they’re entirely about what happens in the moment, and then there are actors who want as much information as possible.
Just like there are writers who write the vomit draft, and there are writers who plan. Everyone’s different. We all hopefully figure out how to work with each other. When you’re directing, every actor is different, and you have to change as much as you can for each one of them, but you can’t go beyond the limits of who you are. They’ll complain about you inevitably. I’m sure there’s some actors who have been sitting in a tent going, “Paul’s not gi–” Then it’s like that doesn’t matter, because the result matters. He makes great movies, so his method works.
John: There was a scene, a sequence in a thing I did last week where a character is exiting a scene, and we’re on the character as they’re exiting the scene, and there’s a lot going on in that person’s head. I actually do describe what’s going on in their head, because they are playable moments. I’m not telling you exactly what your face looks like, but this is what you’re actually going through, and I needed to have that in the script. The clean exit just didn’t make sense.
Craig: Just walk away doesn’t give anybody anything. When you’re doing television, and other directors are involved, it’s even more important. If I’m writing a movie, probably I would go closer to what Paul Thomas Anderson does, which is to put as little in there as possible, because I’ll be there, no matter what, every day. On a television show, you also have other directors that are working on the show. They need this stuff, or else they’re going to fill in whatever they think, and it might not be what you want.
John: Honestly, if I hadn’t left that in there, there would be that temptation to shorten the moment, to cut the moment, or just how do I clean it? I said, “No, we are going to stay on here, and the music’s going to be booming, and this is what we’re going to be feeling.” There’s reasons why you need to do it, and also respect that you need things.
Craig: I would say to our friend in Oslo, don’t worry about it. It is tempting to want to borrow a method from somebody else that’s successful, but other people that are just as successful have the opposite method. You do what feels right and good for you in your process. Your process is its own thing. The goal would be to make things that are so true to you and so good that, one day, somebody’s talking about you and your method and wondering if they should be doing it like you, to which you would say, “No, do it like you should.” That’s my advice to you; don’t sweat it.
One Cool Thing
↑ Back to Top
John: All right, it’s time for our One Cool Things. Craig, sometimes on the show, I get the benefit of being slightly ahead of popular culture, because I get the gay culture before it gets to the mainstream.
Craig: Damn it.
John: Hit & Run I knew before other people knew about Hit & Run before it broke contagion
Craig: Damn you.
John: This is a book that I think could break contagion. It’s Fruit Fly by Josh Silver.
Craig: Fruit Fly?
John: Fruit Fly.
Craig: Great title.
John: It is a book that is described in its official things as a “satirical thriller,” but it’s really a story about appropriation and about who can tell which stories. There’s a British novelist, there is a troubled young man, and their intersecting lives. I’m enjoying it. I’m halfway through it, so I don’t even know how it ends, but I’m enjoying reading it, and I do feel like it’s a thing that could escape contagion. If our listeners want to be slightly ahead of the rest of mainstream culture, you can read Fruit Fly by Josh Silver.
Craig: Now, nothing you said in the description connects me back to your first statement, which is that it’s part of gay culture.
John: The young man in it is involved in chemsex and other–
Craig: What’s chemsex?
John: That’s sex on drugs.
Craig: We used to just call that sex with drugs.
John: Yes, but now it’s a special subculture within–
Craig: Chemsex.
John: Chemsex.
Craig: That sounds so like William Gibson, Neuromancer, kind of like, “He came out of a three-hour chemsex session.”
John: There’s an aspect of that. It’s party culture, but it’s also the drugs that are used in club culture, but also–
Craig: Poppers?
John: Oh, no.
Craig: Ecstasy.
John: Tina, as in crystal meth, and–
Craig: Wait, crystal meth is called Tina?
John: Yes.
Craig: When did that happen?
John: It happened. T, and then G–
Craig: What’s G?
John: G, I don’t know what the actual real name, what the real chemical is, but they’re both dissociative things. Ketamine is also being part of this.
Craig: Ketamine, sure. Everything gets one letter, because you’re so paralyzed you can’t get any more out of your mouth than, “T-T-T.” Tina?
John: Yes, T.
Craig: I’ve got to know how that came from crystal meth. Christina Meth.
John: Christina Meth, probably. Something I don’t know.
Craig: That’s pretty great. Actually, Christina Meth is a great drag queen name. I might take that one. Have you gone out there and made an offer to get the rights to this thing, or what?
John: Halfway through, I don’t think it’s a feature. I don’t think it’s a feature or a TV show. I think it relies on an interiority of personal experience, and so I don’t know that it actually can break out.
Craig: Sometimes a book can just be a book.
John: A book can just be a book.
Craig: Just be a book. Okay, but one cool thing is, this one, Melissa turned me onto this one. There’s a million stores in the United States that are mailbox stores. They’re like, “Come here and we’ll send your stuff to UPS, FedEx, drop it off, pick it up, plus private mailboxes and so forth.” There is one in Toluca Lake, which those people who are not local to Los Angeles, it’s a lovely suburb right next to Burbank here in Los Angeles, near the Universal Studios and Warner Brothers.
John: Is Toluca Lake the city of Los Angeles or the city of Burbank or unincorporated?
Craig: That’s a good que– I don’t think it’s its own city. I think it may just be Los Angeles County.
Meredith: Google says it’s an affluent 1.22-square-mile residential neighborhood in the southeastern San Fernando Valley region of Los Angeles.
Craig: Yes, Los Angeles. Not surprisingly, there’s a store called Mailbox Toluca Lake where you can go drop off your UPS. Also, and this is what I love about Los Angeles, the man who runs it has turned it into perhaps the best collection of supplies for singers for their throats. In addition to mailing stuff, it has products for professional vocalists, whether they’re having dryness, coughing, or laryngitis. He’s got sprays, teas, syrups, tinctures, all of it. In fact, the big ENTs who treat all the singers will send their people to go buy this and that. I just think that that’s wonderful.
John: I think it’s great too.
Craig: If you own a mailbox-something store, you probably have a shelf where you could do whatever you want, and you can fill a niche that is so– I love that. Way to go, Mailbox Toluca Lake. If you’re a singer or you just have some throat needs, they are your people. Then I have one not-cool thing, John. Can I talk about my one not-cool thing?
John: Absolutely.
Craig: It’s a spell. We got to go a little D&D. There’s a new sourcebook out, Forgotten Realms: Heroes of Faerûn. That’s published by Wizards of the Coast. It’s an official sourcebook for D&D. They always put some new spells in these things. I’m watching as Lauren’s eyes slowly get heavier. I’m watching her go to sleep. I just want people to know if they’re not watching this. There’s a spell called Elminster’s Elusion, as in to elude someone. Not illusion.
John: Oh, okay, [crosstalk]
Craig: It’s clever. Elminster, one of the great wizards of all time, obviously.
John: Along with Bigby and Mordenkainen.
Craig: Right up there with Tasha and Alustriel. Here’s Elminster, Halaster Blackcloak. It’s a level two spell. It’s a bonus action. Oh my God. Now we’re talking like Misty Step. It’s concentration. It lasts up to 10 minutes.
John: Sure. I can’t think of a lot of bonus spells that are concentration spells.
Craig: Correct. There’s a good reason, because it’s a bad idea. This spell, if you’re like a high-level wizard, you cast this thing, and then you just smack someone with your 3d10 Fire Bolt. It’s a hell of a turn. Here’s what it says. “Arcane Wards protect you against magic for the duration, 10 minutes. You have advantage on saving throws against spells and magical effects.” Advantage. Probably you’re going to have some pretty good numbers there to hit whatever their checks are. If you succeed on a saving throw with advantage, and you would normally take half as much damage, you take no damage.
John: Oh, that’s very powerful.
Craig: That’s insane. That’s insane.
John: That’s like a [unintelligible 01:23:52] evasion.
Craig: Exactly. For all magic for 10 minutes. If it somehow fails you, cast it again. It’s a second-level bonus action. They blew it on this one. As a DM, I banned this from my game. That’s banned.
John: That’s fair.
Craig: That’s straight up banned. At a minimum, it should be a level three spell, but I would actually put it at level five. I personally would put it at level five. I think it’s crazy. It’s game-breaking. I hate it. I apologize to the Heroes of Faerûn. You will not see Elminster’s Elusion, for instance, on the Baldur’s Gate television show. That’s not going to happen. We’re not going to do that.
John: No, that’s right. That’s right.
Craig: Somebody might bring it up and then somebody else might say, “Oh, yes, that’s a horrible spell. No one’s allowed to cast it in the realm.” It’s banned.
John: Craig, we’re going to have such fascinating decisions to make in terms of how we’re portraying spells.
Craig: So many ways to do it. I have a little bit of a support here because the game does provide certain things.
John: You’re coming into it from a very magic-forward place, which was the game.
Craig: Correct. Magic-forward place. They do a great job with the vocal, the verbal components. They don’t ignore the somatic components. There’s one moment where you see-
John: [unintelligible 01:25:05]
Craig: -Jhe’stil Voss, he’s trying to read your mind, and it’s very silly-looking. Honestly, it looks like juggling but without balls. Nobody bothers with material components ever. The verbal components sound great. What the magic actually looks like and sounds like is very cool. It’ll have to be adapted pretty dramatically.
John: There’ll be different choices you’ll make. That’s right.
Craig: Ravenloft still, there’s plenty of magic. I mean, a lot of the same spells exist.
John: Ravenloft also, by definition, canonically, things can look different in there because it’s–
Craig: Different plane, different realm.
John: Yes. Different whole streaming service as well.
Craig: Different streaming. That’s the beauty. I think that’s how they should do it, by the way, is plane by plane. They should be on a different streaming service. Like, I’m on the Prime material. That’s cool.
John: Yes, but what is the Sigil? What is the Nexus? It all goes back to–
Craig: That’s once Paramount, Warner Brothers buys Disney Fox, and then they both make Sony Universal a subsidiary, then we have Sigil.
John: Once we have the singularity of all streaming services, yes.
Craig: There’s one streaming service called Netflapple Mount Rose Sony Dis, and they should call it Sigil.
John: No, yes. It was like, just call it TV. TV.
Craig: They call it TV. Exactly. Yes, that’s where it’s going.
John: That is our show for this week. Scriptnotes is produced by Meredith Stedman with help from Lauren Loesberg. It is edited by Matthew Chilelli. Our outro this week is by Nick Moore. If you have an outro, you can send us a link to ask@johnaugust.com. It’s also the place where you can send questions like the ones we answered today. You’ll find transcripts at johnaugust.com. The Scriptnotes book is available wherever you buy books. Scriptnotes merch is available at Cotton Bureau. If you’d like to see us, not just listen to us, follow us on YouTube and Instagram. Craig, we put the full Aaron Sorkin episode on YouTube. We won’t do that often.
Craig: It’s worth it. That makes sense. By the way, he looks great.
John: Yes, very tan.
Craig: Yes, very tan, which is cool.
John: It’s healthy.
Craig: It gives me hope, because I don’t know how old Aaron Sorkin even is. How old is he?
Meredith: He called John very young during the–
John: Yeah, he called me a young man. It’s always flattering.
Meredith: He’s 65.
Craig: Yes, compared to him, you’re– He’s 10 years older. I’d like to… Good-looking. Good-looking man. Looks healthy. That’s surprising. Most writers, we start to curl up and become like Yoda. I don’t want to be Yoda.
John: No Yoda. If you’d like to read us, please subscribe to our weekly newsletter called Inneresting, which has lots of links to things about writing. A reminder that we are going to be in Austin, so look for us for the live show and also for the three-page challenge. If you want to submit to the three-page challenge, it’s johnaugust.com/threepage, all spelled out.
Most of all, thank you to our premium subscribers. You can sign up to become one of us at scriptnotes.net, where you get all the back episodes and bonus segments like the one we are about to record on festivals. Craig, thanks for a fun show. Welcome back.
Craig: Thank you, John. Glad to be back.
[music]
Bonus Segment
↑ Back to Top
John: All right, Meredith, help us out. I see we have a question about festivals.
Meredith: Yes. Jack writes, “I know that there have been multiple episodes of Scriptnotes live from the Austin Film Festival and that both John and Craig are regular speakers/attenders and general fans of the conference themselves. I’ve heard you both speak effusively about it in the past, and it’s clear that for those who can, you recommend attending. As somebody who has never had the opportunity to go previously, my broader question is this.
As a writer, why would you recommend attending a film festival such as Austin, and what should you expect to get out of it? Are all festivals created equal, and would your advice be different for writers at different stages of their careers? I have never been to any film festival. I have no professional writing experience or credits to my name. I have no industry connections and know nobody else attending. I would love for the opportunity to try and make some connections and get my writing in front of people, but I don’t know how realistic this is or what my expectations should be.
John: We say Austin Film Festival, but really what we’re talking about is the Screenwriters Conference, which is a special thing which starts before the actual film festival does. We can talk about Austin separately.
Craig: It’s a different thing.
John: It’s a different thing, which is just a bunch of screenwriters coming together. That’s where we have panels, and we do those things. Back episodes, we’ve talked a lot about what to do at the Austin Film Festival.
Craig: We should call it the Austin Screenwriting Conference. The truth is, it’s unique. A film festival typically is a lot of movies. That’s what it is, a lot of movies, and there’s a competition. There is a simultaneous one of those, which is not particularly big time. Like the Austin Film Festival is not something that people are looking to get the little laurels on their poster for. It really is a little rider along with the Austin Screenwriting Conference, which is very much about bringing people from Hollywood who are professional writers to talk to people who want to be professional writers. It’s as simple as that.
John: The Austin experience is special and different, but let’s talk about festivals in general and film festivals in general and what a writer or an aspiring writer-director might want to think about in terms of attending one of these things. For me, the advantage to going to your local festival or some other festival is the chance to see a bunch of movies you wouldn’t otherwise see and get a sense of what it looks like to make small-budget films and the range at which you can do these things.
You see movies that are going to be made for $100,000 or $5 million and what that looks like, how they’re put together, what do you actually like, and get a sense of your taste. Sometimes get a little glimpse of the future of, like, “Oh, this is a great director. I’m going to look for all their stuff down the road.” There will be other panels, conferences, discussions there where you can hear about how they made their things, which, if you’re thinking about how to make stuff, is incredibly valuable in terms of the nuts and bolts of how they got a thing made. That, I think, is crucial.
Craig: I think you put your finger on it. If you want to write and perhaps direct a film that is the sort of film that would require a film festival or that film festivals would be interested in, it makes total sense to go see what they’re interested in. What kind of movies does the festival accept? What is the standard that you’re trying to hit? If you are trying to do more like what you and I do, I don’t think you need to go. I’ve never been to one in my life. How about that? Not once. Ya know, I’m the worst.
John: You’re not the worst–
Craig: No, I’m the worst. I really am. I think about our friend, Phil Hay. He’s gone to Telluride so many times– He loves movies and goes to those things. I have friends that have gone to TIFF, that’s a big one, Toronto International Film Festival. We have friends that have been to Cannes and all this stuff. I don’t know what any of it’s like. Hey, John, can I ask you a question? Do you know the thing where at these film festivals people get the 12-minute standing ovation?
John: That thing is crazy.
Craig: Can I curse on this one?
John: Yes.
Craig: What the fuck is that? What the fuck is that? Who wants that? How do you stand there for 12 minutes? What happens? Do you know how long 12 minutes is? Have we talked about this before?
John: So, so long.
Craig: What is that? I want to do it on this show. I want to applaud for 12 minutes.
John: We can do that in Austin.
Craig: We just do it.
John: We can just do it. Let’s see what that shit feels like.
Craig: We’re just going to do it just to see how uncomfortable it is and how weird. Do you know when you say a word over and over, it starts to get weird? Do people start to fall in love with each other in this? What happens? Do people go insane?
John: It’s starting to die down, and people realize it’s starting to die down.
Craig: Then it happens more. Just like, do you hypnotize yourself? What is happening? No one can do anything just like that for 12 minutes. What is that? It almost seems like they’re mocking these movies. I find this horrifying. Anyway, I want to know what that’s about. Somebody should have a sense of the history of that. When did it start, and what is this bizarre affectation?
John: I suspect we can find some good articles about the history of it.
Craig: The madness of this stupid thing. We’re going to applaud for 12 minutes. I’ll see a show. I’m going to see Oh, Mary! when I get back in November, which I’m so excited about. I’ve got to so many wonderful showing, seeing the original cast of Hamilton. When it’s over, you applaud them for a good minute. It seems like an eternity, but they deserved it. They just did it there for you. They’re sweating.
John: 100%.
Craig: It’s their fourth of eight shows that week or whatever it is. This is a movie. It’s over. It’s done. People are just, they’re sipping pina coladas and watching you. They’re standing there in their suits. Anyway, this is not what this person wanted.
John: Yes, so Jack wanted to know.
Craig: Here’s what Jack wanted to know. Clearly, I don’t know what I’m talking about, Jack.
John: Normal film festivals, I think a writer could take from this, is you go to see a [unintelligible 01:34:15]. You love this director’s film. It’s like, “I’m writing a thing that is maybe right for that director.” You would be surprised how well you might be able to get to-
Craig: To actually talk to them.
John: -connect to that director and find a way to do things.
Craig: Although, of course, that director’s like, “Can you guys, please stop telling people to come up to me at film festivals and pitch their ideas?” Because if you’re at one of these things and someone’s like, “Hey, I have an idea that I think would be good for you,” what do you say?
John: I would give them Drew’s email address and tell them to email Drew.
Craig: No, I would not. What I would say is, “I’m so sorry, but I’m not allowed to accept anything.”
John: If a director has their first film at a festival or something they directed but they didn’t write, especially, that’s an opportunity. Even if you didn’t talk to them at the festival, you’re going to find a way to get in touch with them.
Craig: Well, you know, tip, pro tip for you guys out there. If you get yourself in a conversation with somebody like that, not one of the after-the-session, everybody crowds around somebody, but you’re at a bar, they’re there. You say, “Hey, listen, I saw your movie. I thought it was fantastic. Can I just talk to you for a minute about why I loved it?” Talk to them about why you loved it.
A conversation will occur. Then, out of that conversation, if you happen to mention what you’re doing, happen to mention something you’re thinking about, and it sparks their interest, guess what? There you go. You’re off and running. It’s not like, “Hey, hello, my name is so-and-so. I saw your movie. I have something that I think you should do,” and now it’s just a sales pitch.
John: You actually have more than just the 10 seconds of “Your thing was good, and now here’s my thing.” That’s not going to work.
Craig: Exactly. That would be awkward and bad.
John: Thanks, Craig.
Craig: Thank you, John.